The world's most in-depth and scientific product reviews

Best Photo Printer

Credit: Laura Casner
By Nick Miley, Jason Peters and Austin Palmer  ⋅  Oct 30, 2020
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
Some people say it's not a picture until you print it. With this in mind, we bought and tested the best 13 best photo printers on the market. These machines range from battery-powered mini-printers to full-sized desktop machines that will pump out professional-grade images on a cornucopia of mediums in an array of dimensions. While our in-house photography team tested for image quality, the office egg-heads analyzed the short and long-term costs of printing. With the complete picture that our research provides, you'll be able to confidently pick the best photo printer to fit your needs.

Top 13 Product Ratings

Displaying 1 - 5 of 13
< Previous | Compare | Next >
 
Awards Editors' Choice Award  Best Buy Award  Best Buy Award 
Price $800 List$500 List$350 List$250 List
$256 at Amazon
$100 List
$79.99 at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
84
79
67
60
58
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Broad print dimensions, vast print mediums, low print costs, fantastic image fidelityHigh resolution, vivid colors, great dynamic rangeConsistent color, easy set-up, broad format optionsGreat color rendition, good dynamic range, good tonal rangeEasy to use, decent resolution, prints common sizes
Cons Huge footprint, expensiveHard to set-up, big footprintMicrobanding in grayscale, relatively low definition in dark areasPoor resolution, few paper options, relatively expensiveMicrobanding in larger formats, off skin tones, over saturation
Bottom Line This near-professional quality machine leaves little to be desiredThis is a top-tier, professional level printer at a reasonable priceThis printer yields high-quality images at a reasonable priceThis spendy machine is among the best of mid-size printers in color rendition and dynamic rangeA quality mid-size machine that will appeal to the casual user
Rating Categories Epson SureColor P600 Canon PIXMA Pro-100 Expression Photo... Epson PictureMate... Canon PIXMA TR4520
Color (35%)
8
8
6
5
6
Black And White (35%)
9
9
7
7
6
Print Capabilities (15%)
9
7
8
5
5
Operating Cost (10%)
8
7
7
7
5
Set Up (5%)
6
4
5
6
6
Specs Epson SureColor P600 Canon PIXMA Pro-100 Expression Photo... Epson PictureMate... Canon PIXMA TR4520
Resolutioin (dots per inch) 5760 x 1440 4800 x 2400 5760 x 1440 5760 x 1440 4800 x 1200
Max photo deminsions (inches) 13" x 129" 13" x 19" 13" x 44" 5" x 7" 8" x 10"
Cost per print (4" x 6" or mini print) $0.36 $0.40 $0.45 $0.45 $0.58
Machine deminsions (HxWxD inches) 9" x 24.2" x 14.5" 8.5" x 27.2" x 15.2" 6.3" x 18.7" x 14.5" 3.3" x 9" x 6.9" 7.5" x 17.2" x 11.7"
Printing technology Inkjet (Piezo DOD) Inkjet (Theromal DOD) Inkjet (Piezo DOD) Inkjet (Piezo DOD) Inkjet (Theromal DOD)
Print time per 4" x 6" (or mini print) 63 seconds 55 seconds 34 seconds 86 seconds 128 seconds
Color palette (ink cartridges) Matte Black, Cyan, Vivid Magenta, Yellow, Light Cyan, Vivid Light Magenta, Light Black, Light Light Black Black, Gray, Light Gray, Cyan, Photo Cyan, Magenta, Photo Magenta, Yellow Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Black, Gray, Red Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Black Black plus color cartridge
LCD screen Yes No Yes Yes No
Touch Screen Yes No No No No
Battery No No No No No
Memory cards supported N/A N/A N/A SD, SDHC, SDXC, MiniSD, MiniSDHC, MicroSD, MicroSDHC, MicroSDXC N/A
Ink type Pigment-based Dye-based Dye-based Dye-based Pigment (black) and dye-based (color)
Roller paper Yes No No No No
Connectivity Apple AirPrint and Google Cloud Print support; USB 2.0, Wireless n1, Wi-Fi Direct1 and 100Mbit Ethernet, Hi-Speed USB 2.0 (1 port), 100Base-T Ethernet (1 port), Wi-Fi CERTIFIED (802.11n only), Wi-Fi Direct
Epson Connect 4: Epson iPrint Mobile App, Apple Airprint, Google Cloud Print
Wireless LAN (IEEE 802.11 b/g/n), Ethernet
Hi-Speed USB, PictBridge (Cable not included)
iPad, iPhone and Android tablets, Alexa and smartphones; Ethernet networking, andard Connectivity:
Hi-Speed USB, USB Host, Wireless 802.11 b/g/n5, Wi-Fi Direct 5, Ethernet 10/100
Hi-Speed USB 2.0/Wireless 802.11 b/g/n5, WiFi Direct4 Printing from a Mobile Device:
Epson Connect 6, Epson Email Print, Epson iPrint Mobile App, AirPrint, Google Cloud Print, Android Printing, Remote Print
Hi-Speed USB
Wi-Fi (802.11b/g/n wireless networking, 2.4 GHz)
Operating system requirements Apple macOS 10.13.x-10.12.x, OS X: 10.11x-10.7x
&
Microsoft Windows®: 10, 8.1, 7 (32-bit, 64-bit)
Windows 7, Windows 7 SP1, Windows Vista SP1, Vista SP2, Windows XP SP3 32-bit Intel processor
Mac OS X v10.5.8 - 10.9.x7
Windows 10 8/8.1/Windows 7 (32-bit, 64-bit)
Windows Vista (32-bit , 64-bit)
Mac OS X 10.6.8 — macOS 10.12.x6
Windows 7 (32-bit, 64-bit), Windows 8.x (32-bit, 64-bit), Windows Vista (32-bit, 64-bit), Windows XP SP3 (32-bit), Windows XP Professional x64 Edition Windows 10, Mac OS X 10.6.8 — 10.10.x8;
Internet access is required to install drivers and software.
Windows:20 Windows 10, Windows 8.1, Windows 7 SP1, Mac:21
Mac OS X v10.10.5 - macOS v10.13 (High Sierra)
Mobile Operating Systems:22 iOS, Android, Windows 10 Mobile, and Fire OS (Amazon Fire) devices
Scanner No No No No Yes (bed and feed)
Touch Screen Yes No No No No

Best Overall Photo Printer


Epson SureColor P600


Epson SureColor P600
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$800
List Price
See It

84
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 8
  • Black and White 9
  • Print Capabilities 9
  • Operating Cost 8
  • Set-Up 6
Cost per print: $0.36 | Maximum Resolution: 1440 dpi
Roll paper
8-color ink palette
Easy operation
High up-front cost
Big desktop footprint

The Epson SureColor P600 offers professional quality printing to the hobbyist. The color and grayscale resolution rendered are top-notch for the class. Complementing the image quality is the wide variety of material that this home printer can accommodate. The SureColor is an expensive machine. However, the low cost per print can eventually add up to significant savings if you are frequently printing.

As is often the case with high-end electronics, a product's strengths can sometimes become detrimental to the wrong user. This is undoubtedly the case with the SureColor, as its large size and hefty price tag will be a burden for the casual photographer. Additionally, if the machine isn't used regularly, clogged printer heads and desiccated ink cartridges will become a time-consuming and expensive problem. That said, if you want to go all-in on photo printing or experiment with different print mediums and dimensions, this machine won't let you down.

Read Full Review: Epson SureColor P600

Best Mini Printer


Canon IVY


Canon IVY
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$99.99
at Amazon
See It

43
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 4
  • Black and White 4
  • Print Capabilities 3
  • Operating Cost 6
  • Set-Up 9
Cost per print: $0.50 | Maximum Resolution: 400 dpi
Easy set-up
Slick design
Sticker photo paper
One size prints
Relatively low resolution

Rekindling the excitement of the Polaroid cameras of yesteryear, the Canon IVY makes photo printing on-the-fly fun and easy. It has a streamlined, compact shape and seamless Bluetooth interaction with your smartphone. The prints are of reasonable quality and have decent resolution when compared to other mini-printers. The ZINK paper that the machine uses has an adhesive back that turns them into stickers, which is a fun perk.

While the IVY makes printing as easy as pushing a button on your phone, its usefulness is somewhat limited, and the cost per print is a bit pricey. This model can only print on one kind of paper, in one set of dimensions (2" x 3"). Moreover, when compared to a desktop photo printer, the photo quality isn't that great. If you just want to play around with a printer, however, and don't want the fuss of maintaining an inkjet machine, the Canon IVY is the ticket.

Read Full Review: Canon IVY

Great Value for a Full-Sized Printer


Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000


Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000
Best Buy Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$350
List Price
See It

67
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 6
  • Black and White 7
  • Print Capabilities 8
  • Operating Cost 7
  • Set-Up 5
Cost per print: $0.45 | Maximum Resolution: 1440 dpi
Great color
Smallest printer capable of 13" x 19" prints
Intuitive setup
Sepia tones in grayscale
Some skin tone issues in large formats

If you want a full-size printer but don't want a full-size hit to your wallet, the Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000 is the machine to thread that needle. This relatively compact model punches well above its weight. It will print in large format, and with the aid of its expansive color palette, it produces vibrant colors that come out nicely across all print formats.

Although there is plenty to praise this machine for, it has shortcomings in overall resolution and in grayscale, where dark tonal transitions can be challenging to discern. Additionally, the dark areas showed some subtle (but noticeable) micro banding. And though the issue seemed to resolve itself over time, we sometimes had issues staying connected to the printer. Despite these critiques, we'd say this is one heck of a printer that most photographers will find more than satisfactory.

Read Full Review: Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000

Best on a Tight Budget


Canon PIXMA TR4520


Canon PIXMA TR4520
Best Buy Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$79.99
(20% off)
at Amazon
See It

58
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 6
  • Black and White 6
  • Print Capabilities 5
  • Operating Cost 5
  • Set-Up 6
Cost per print: $0.58 | Maximum Resolution: 1200 dpi
Good dynamic range
Decent range of print mediums
Good resolution
Some color issues
Microbanding increases with print size

The Canon PIXMA TR4520 is a great mid-sized machine to get you started in home photo printing. What we really enjoyed about this model is that it's cheap and straightforward. In contrast, the higher-end printers tend to be overwhelming for newbies. This product supports the use of standard paper types, allowing you to experiment and see why specific papers work well in some situations and not in others. The print dimensions are limited to the smaller sizes, so you won't need to break the bank learning the craft. And because this machine is relatively compact, you won't have to sacrifice half your desk to house it.

While this machine will appeal to many a neophyte, it certainly has its downfalls. The prints coming out of this model often lack fidelity to the original image. This disparity is most apparent in orangish skin tones and oversaturated blues. Additionally, because its best color results are seen on higher quality paper, the machine has above average printing costs. That said, your efforts won't be in vain, as this machine can render better results than the average photo lab.

Read Full Review: Canon PIXMA TR4520

Best for Easy 4" x 6" Prints


Canon SELPHY CP1300


Canon SELPHY CP1300
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$128.98
at Amazon
See It

58
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 6
  • Black and White 6
  • Print Capabilities 4
  • Operating Cost 7
  • Set-Up 5
Cost per print: $0.43 | Maximum Resolution: 300 dpi
Convenient
Fun
Decent quality prints
Tricky to set-up
One paper type

The Canon SELPHY CP1300 is a significant step-up in quality from the mini-printers, but it maintains the same appeal. The machine is compact, transportable, and can even run off a battery (sold separately). If you are looking to get all those great photos off your phone and onto your friends' fridges, this is the kind of printer to get. The photo quality is better than the average chain's photo lab, and the cost isn't too much higher. It's also fun to watch the machine at work. Seriously. The paper passes back and forth through the machine layering on the different inks, allowing you to see the CMYK color model in action.

The only real criticism against the SELPHY is that it's limited to just a few print sizes and uses Canon's glossy proprietary paper. Additionally, we weren't surprised to see that a printer of this size had some problems with streaking issues and color fidelity — but honestly, they weren't too bad. Conversely, we were pleasantly surprised that the skin tones and transitions in grayscale were pretty much spot-on.

Read Full Review: Canon SELPHY CP1300

Best for Old School Polaroid-style Prints


Fujifilm Instax Mini Link


Fujifilm Instax Mini Link
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$100
List Price
See It

27
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Color 2
  • Black and White 2
  • Print Capabilities 3
  • Operating Cost 4
  • Set-Up 9
Cost per print: $0.64 | Maximum Resolution: 318 dpi
Classic look
Ease of use
Poor resolution
Low dynamic range

Despite being one of the poorest-performing printers we have reviewed, the Fujifilm Instax Mini Link scored style points for its use of classic Polaroid-type paper. It didn't matter that the images had low resolution or poor colors. A well-composed photo with vintage fat borders and heavy paper just stirs up feelings of nostalgia that the other instant printers can't match.

On the other hand, there's plenty to criticize about the Mini Link, though it seems a bit ridiculous to point them all out. Sure, it has a limited range of colors, terrible resolution, and a high cost per print. This clearly is not the machine for you if you're looking for high-quality prints. However — and we might be showing our age here — we just think the format looks cool.

Read Full Review: Fujifilm Instax Mini Link


A selection from the models we tested.
A selection from the models we tested.
Credit: Laura Casner

Why You Should Trust Us?


Our review team brings product-specific expertise to the testing and rating of photo printers. In-House Photographer Jason Peters was born with a sharp eye that was further honed at Brooks Institute of Photography. His education saw him to studio work in L.A. and eventually landed him here at the GearLab. Our seasoned Review Analyst Austin Palmer brings to the mix over five years of consumer electronics testing and photography experience. His attention to such details as long-term printer costs is invaluable. Finally, Senior Review Editor Nick Miley is a photography hobbyist and occasional freelancer who doesn't think a photo is complete until the print is in a frame and on the wall.

Together, this trio selected a series of color and grayscale images to cover all aspects of rendering a high-quality photo and then printed them on various paper types in several different sizes. In the end, over 320 pictures were printed for the initial analysis. The team set up a viewing room devoid of shadow and glare to comparatively analyze the printers' outputs. They also had the office staff print their pictures to test the ease of connecting to and operating the machines. Finally, each printer's features and specifications were collected, measured in-house (if possible), and organized for comparison.

Related: How We Tested Photo Printers

Analysis and Test Results


Our testing regimen is divided into five weighted metrics — Color, Black and White, Print Capabilities, Set-up, and Operating Costs. These metrics include a deep dive into the visual quality of the prints, the dimensions and mediums used, the machine's ease of use, and the cost of printing. Each metric is weighted to account for a percentage of the final 1 -100 point score based on its impact on the user's experience. Below is a detailed account of the tests that make up each metric and how they reveal the market's best machines.

Related: Buying Advice for Photo Printers


Value


Our method for assessing value takes two different approaches to reach the same endpoint. We are looking for a product that either performs at a similar level to other products but costs less, or a product that performs at a higher level than similarly priced competitors. Examples of these two types of value are the Canon PIXMA TR4520 and the Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000. The XP-15000 is a full-sized photo printer that's priced significantly below the cost of other machines that render larger format prints. On the other hand, the TR4520 has a sticker price similar to the mini-printers, yet delivers quality 8" x 10" prints. Both of these machines supply serious savings to consumers.

Side-by-side comparative analysis was critical to our judgment of...
Side-by-side comparative analysis was critical to our judgment of print quality.
Credit: Laura Casner

Color


Most people want to print in color. With that in mind, we weighted this metric to account for 35% of a printer's overall score. As the basis for our analysis of color prints, we purchased seven stock images that spanned subjects from portraits to landscapes and collectively covered a wide dynamic range. We printed in several dimensions from the mini printers' 2" x 3" up to 13" x 19" with the full-size models. We also tested a variety of paper types when possible to see which rendered the best results.


Our assessment of the prints relied on the eyes of both professional photographers and laypeople. The assessment had two parts. First, we rated each print on the overall impression it gave the viewer. The focus was on clearly defined borders, smooth tonal transitions, and skin tone (for the images that featured people). The overall impression also focused on the print's fidelity compared to the original image displayed on a high-resolution monitor. The second part of the color metric honed in on the print's resolution and sharpness.

Full-size prints from a full-size printer. Just look at those colors!
Full-size prints from a full-size printer. Just look at those colors!
Credit: Laura Casner

The full-size printers excelled in this evaluation, with the EPSON SureColor living up to its name and the Canon PIXMA Pro-100 delivering similar results. The standard that these printers set in image fidelity, resolution, and consistency across multiple paper dimensions left a big gap between them and the rest of the class. However, also showing up big, the Canon SELPHY and the Canon PIXMA TR4520 proved that mid-size printers don't have to kick out middling quality prints. The chief complaint with the SELPHY was streaking, while the PIXMA was guilty of micro banding, but you have to look close to notice these shortfalls. The quality is still substantially better than prints produced by many big chain photo labs. Finally, when we compared the Canon IVY to its mini printer peers, it provided the best color images of the lot, though they were far from what the desktop printers can deliver.

Grayscale goes a long way in revealing the definition and tonal...
Grayscale goes a long way in revealing the definition and tonal transitions of a print.
Credit: Laura Casner

Black and White


Black and white prints can reveal more about the boundary definition and tonal transitions of an image than you may see in the busy brightness of a color print. Despite the less frequent use of grayscale, the heavy demands that this format places on a printer caused us to weigh this metric the same as the color at 35% of the total score.


The black and white evaluation protocols reflected those used for the color prints, the exception being that the images chosen for inspection were in grayscale. Again, the EPSON SureColor and the Canon PIXMA Pro-100 shot the moon in this evaluation. These printers have an advantage in this metric because they boast three separate ink cartridges in shades of black and gray. The Epson has fantastic tonal range, tonal contrasts, and brilliant definition. However, outputs across all dimensions displayed hints of magenta, which yielded a cooler tone. The Canon delivered similarly high-quality results, but the prints showed some green tones, lending the printed images a warmer feel.

There&#039;s nothing like the pop that good contrast creates in a black...
There's nothing like the pop that good contrast creates in a black and white print.
Credit: Laura Casner

As with the color metric, there was a significant step-down in quality from the full to the mid-sized machines. However, the Epson Expression and the Epson Picturemate were standouts in their size-class. The large format, 13" x 19" prints produced by the Expression were nearly on par with the full-sized machines. Interestingly, the quality fell off incrementally as the print dimensions decreased, with banding and streaking becoming more apparent. The PictureMate was much more consistent across the various print dimensions. Despite displaying tone qualities similar to the full-sized machines, this model suffered from a reduction in resolution.

The time to print a 4&quot; x 6&quot; was just one aspect of the print...
The time to print a 4" x 6" was just one aspect of the print capabilities metric.
Credit: Laura Casner

Print Capabilities


The print capabilities metric includes a mixture of cataloging and testing features. Specifically, we cataloged the number of ink cartridges the printers use, the range of print dimensions they can produce, and the applicable print substrates. These are materials like matte and glossy paper, as well as less common mediums like artboard and canvas. We also tested the print speed and paper tray capacity. This metric accounts for just 15% of a printer's overall score.


Yet again, the Epson SureColor was the top dog. There truly isn't much this machine can't do. It can print from 3.5" x 5" up to 13" x 129", making room-spanning panoramic prints possible. Additionally, the SureColor can print on every medium from glossy paper to canvas. Moreover, its nine separate ink cartridges give it a real leg up over the competition. On the SureColor's heels is the Epson Expression, which covers all the standard print sizes from 2" x 6" up to 13" x 44". Although this machine doesn't include the more exotic print mediums, it is compatible with a wide variety of photo papers and has seven individual color cartridges.

Nine individual ink cartridges? That will render one heck of a...
Nine individual ink cartridges? That will render one heck of a palette.
Credit: Laura Casner

Compared to the Epson models discussed above, the rest of the printers in the class fall off. However, the Canon PIXMA Pro-100 and the HP Tango deserve honorable mentions for covering a broad range of papers and print dimensions. The former has eight ink cartridges, while the latter has four.

Finally, we clocked the time it takes each machine to pump out a 4" x 6" color print (or, in the case of the mini printers, a mini print). While it might not seem that important, if you are printing lots of photos (or very large ones), the risk of something going wrong may keep you close to the machine. Thus, all other aspects of the print being equal, faster is better. The class average for this exercise was 56 seconds. On the swift end was the FujiFilm Instax Mini Link at just 9 seconds, though the photo paper develops after the print is kicked out of the machine. The Canon PIXMA TR4520 is on the very slow end of the class, at 128 seconds.

Don&#039;t forget to include long-term costs to the price of the printer...
Don't forget to include long-term costs to the price of the printer. We expressed this in the cost per 4" x 6" color print.
Credit: Laura Casner

Operating Cost


Operating cost measures the long-term expense of the machines we tested, and we weighted it with 10% of a printer's overall score. This metric addresses the question of how much it costs to produce a single 4" x 6" print. To get this figure, we used the industry's conservative estimate of ink consumption per square inch of color printing and multiplied that by 24 (square inches). The product of this equation was then added to the cost of a 4" x 6" sheet of moderate quality glossy photo paper. Although the higher-end printers produce much less expensive prints, the upfront cost of the printer is significant. The opposite is true of lower-end printers.


The Epson SureColor is in a league of its own in this evaluation, producing 4" x 6" images for $0.36 each, which is about what you'd pay for a print at a chain photo lab. However, the Epson's quality is much better than the store-bought prints. Epson's Expression and PictureMate, as well as Canon's SELPHY and PIXMA Pro-100, fall in the 40 - 45 cent range. The mini printers are arguably the most expensive because one needs to print two mini prints to get an equivalent size image that the rest of the machines are rendering.

Many of the smaller printers use an app to print pictures directly...
Many of the smaller printers use an app to print pictures directly from a smartphone. This feature often makes set-up a cinch.
Credit: Laura Casner

Set-Up


While set-up is a one-time operation — or at least an infrequent one — it is annoying if it's unnecessarily complicated. Given the duration of this phase of printer ownership, we weighted this metric to account for just 5% of a printer's overall score. Our evaluation went as follows: read the set-up instructions carefully, follow them exactly, and see if we can print from our phone or laptop. If the process goes off without a hitch, the printer scores high. If we have to do some troubleshooting, the score goes down. Additionally, we had members of our staff who were not directly involved with this review go through the same process and voice their complaints.


The easiest printers to get running were the mini printers, by far. For these machines, you simply download an app on your phone and give the app permission to access your photos and camera. If you know how to download an app, take a picture, edit and share it, you shouldn't have any problems with these machines. On the opposite end of the spectrum are printers like the Canon PIXMA Pro-100, which require you to download a driver onto your computer but lack an LCD screen to aid you in the set-up. Other annoying aspects of set-up are machines like the HP Tango Smart that get locked into a particular computer at the exclusion of others. For example, if you want to print from a co-worker's computer, you will have to plug it in directly to the printer with a USB — a detail we discovered through trial and error.

Full-size printers, particularly those without an LCD screen, are...
Full-size printers, particularly those without an LCD screen, are the most difficult to get running. However, it is a one-time operation and the difficulty is quickly forgotten when the prints come pouring out.
Credit: Laura Casner

Conclusion


Our review of photo printers delves deeply into all the features and specifications that make for a quality machine. We detailed color and grayscale rendering as well as the challenges of working in each medium. We assessed the different printing substrates that the machines can print on, the dimensions of those materials, and the rendering times of common materials. In the form of price per print, we calculated the long-term operating expenses of each machine. Finally, we made an in-depth assessment of the set-up of the printers. Given the breadth and depth of this information, we hope that you now have a well-resolved picture of which machines performed the best and which are best suited to meet your needs and budget.

Nick Miley, Jason Peters and Austin Palmer