Best Sling Camera Bag
With over 40-years of making camera bags, Tenba is a brand known for quality. The Tenba Messenger DNA 15 lives up to that reputation. This bag is built well and features good weather resistance. After a heavy 5-minute shower, we didn't find any moisture in the main compartment of the bag, and that's without using the included rain fly. The Tenba is cavernous, with a capacity that rivals many backpacks we've tested — it can fit two cameras with lenses attached plus two or three spare lenses. It is deep enough for a 70-200 with a DSLR attached. Even while carrying all your camera gear, there's still enough room for your 15" laptop, tablet, and most of what you need for your mobile office. Pockets are abundant in this bag; we counted 22 in total, including two water bottle pockets. The pockets allow customized organization for the user's individual needs. This bag gives you two ways to access your camera, first is by lifting the flap held by velcro. Velcro is normally quite loud to open, but Tenba brings a technology they call Whisper hook. Whisper hook allows quiet opening by pulling down on the hood then opening it; we love this detail. If opening the hood is too slow, they offer a zipper at the top that lets you bypass it. A nice final touch is that the camera organization is removable, giving you the option just to have a big messenger bag.
While this was the most comfortable shoulder bag when fully loaded, this bag is strenuous to wear on long days. At times we found the number of pockets could be overwhelming, making it easy to forget exactly where we stowed that lens cap. We also couldn't find a convenient way to carry a tripod with this bag. We could store it under the main flap of the pack, but then it was clumsy and time-consuming to access the bag.
We found the Peak Design Everyday Sling 10L to be the Goldilocks of sling camera bags; it's not too big, nor too small but just right — big enough to shoot out of all day, without weighing us down by being so big that we want to bring everything we own. The Everyday Sling carries tight to your back but with a quick-release strap adjust. It's easy to loosen and pull around to the front of your body. This bag has minimalistic stylings, with only two external zipped pockets and clean lines. The first of those pockets takes you to the main camera compartment, which comfortably carries a medium-sized lens with a camera attached, a 70-200, and another medium lens. This bag only comes with two internal dividers, and they are the most clever dividers we've seen. Offering origami-like folding capabilities gives you many options for storage. Inside the top flap of this pocket is an organization compartment that is perfect for storing your batteries. In the main chamber is a tablet sleeve. The second external zipper leads to an expanding organization pocket. When we say expanding, it goes from lying flat to being able to hold a 1-liter Nalgene bottle. That pocket includes soft-lined organization pockets that are great for sunglasses or a phone. If you find yourself stuck in the rain more than you would like, then this bag would be a great pick. It was a top performer in our rain stress test.
It's important to stress that the main drawback to this model is that it's on the smaller side — you cannot carry everything in this bag. It is too small to fit a 13" MacBook pro comfortably. Sure, you can squeeze it in, but we don't recommend it. We opted for carrying a tablet instead. Some of our testers found the strap to be too thin and underpadded to be comfortable with heavier loads, while other testers didn't have an issue with that.
For those that are just getting into photography, the AmazonBasics Large Camera Bag is great. It offers classic top-loading access to your camera, which is quick and simple to use while simultaneously allowing you extra protection by zipping the compartment closed. With the price tag of this bag, we didn't have high hopes for weather resistance. Those doubts didn't manifest, and we were surprised by its performance. This contender did well in our 5-minute shower stress test; we found no water in the camera compartment. The bright orange internal liner makes it easy to see all your dark camera gear. Four colorful dividers batch the lining and make it easy to organize your gear how you need to. The AmazonBasics bag offers basic organizational pockets and a tablet sleeve that we found to be big enough for small tablets.
Unfortunately, this bag isn't tall enough to hold a standard sized 70-200. While it'll keep a 70-200 lens attached to a mirrorless body lengthwise, with that setup, there is no additional room in the bag for other lenses. It lacked comfort, which we found the most significant drawback to this model. We walked over a mile with it fully loaded and slung over our shoulders, and our bodies weren't too pleased. This bag's construction isn't that great either. Using flimsy plastic buckles and single stitching keeps the cost down but also leaves us wondering if it will last as long as other bags we tested. Outside of the photography compartment, this model has minimal space to hold accessories. While it does feature straps for a tripod, we found the extra weight made it even more burdensome and preferred to use those straps for something like a jacket.
The Peak Design Everyday Messenger 15" has the simple, sleek look that Peak Design is known for. The detail-oriented approach to this bag makes it user friendly for a day out. These details make everything easier, from the main compartment's magnetic closure to the quick-adjust buckle on the strap. The bag's main compartment can carry a DSLR with a medium lens attached, another medium, and a large lens with room to spare. That main compartment comes with three origami folding dividers to keep your equipment protected and organized. A zipper on top of the flap allows you access to your camera without opening the flap. Inside the main compartment, there's another drop-in pocket perfect for a memory card wallet or sunglasses. If you are one of those people who believes everything has its place, you will appreciate the front organization pocket, which features eight stretch mesh pockets. Out of all the bags we tested, this model features the most comprehensive load stabilizing straps. It can be worn as a waist belt or worn from a corner of the bag to the shoulder strap to suit your style. Either way, we found that these helped tremendously to stabilize the bag while riding a bike. Peak Design has an ecosystem of products that can all be used independently but are all designed to work together seamlessly.
The strap is 2" wide and has integrated padding, and while we like the look and idea of this pad, we found it a little bit flimsy for just how much weight you can put in the bag. We appreciate the place to carry a tripod under the main opening flap of the pack, but when you do so, you significantly interfere with how easy the bag is to access. Because of that, we often found ourselves leaving the tripod home. A 15" laptop is the functional capacity of this model. Our 16" Macbook Pro is a tight fit, and it is harder to get out of this bag than we would have liked.
As a longtime workhorse brand for photojournalists, Domke has been making durable, trustworthy bags for decades. The Domke F-5XB maintains its well-built, simple, understated design and gets its durability from its thick, waxed canvas. Domke believes, as do we, that if you care for this bag correctly, it will be with you for years. To set you off on the right foot for caring for this bag, they send you a container of wax. You have two choices in how to wear this model: either over the shoulder with a strap, or ditch the shoulder strap and wear it on your belt. We found that we used this bag when we were out with just one camera and needed to carry a couple of extra lenses and some accessories.
This bag is simple, to the point of having almost no organizational pockets. Two drop-in pockets run the full length of the pack. The first one is under the Velcro flap on the front of the bag; the second is right behind the first, inside the bag, between the padding of the camera compartment and the waxed canvas. That pocket is big enough to slip in an iPad Mini if you wanted to. However, we wouldn't necessarily recommend doing that with no padding on the outside of that pocket. We opted, instead, to store a notebook and pen in that pocket.
The ONA Bowery is a simple yet elegant bag made with beautiful materials. Waxed Canvas with genuine full-grain leather trim and brass hardware gives this bag classic styling coupled with incredible durability. This bag is well-padded, including the bottom, which has a rigid plastic core for extra protection. When cared for properly, we believe this model will be protecting your gear for years to come. It comes with a simple 1.5" webbing shoulder strap that is comfortable for the bag's size. We found this model great for cruising the city with a camera and a couple of lenses. It has five external drop-in pockets; two on the front, which are 5" wide and 4" tall, two on the bag's sides, and the fifth is a full-length pocket found on the back.
The downsides of the Bowery are that the external pockets are flat, don't offer much space, and are also hard to utilize. The pockets are difficult to remove items from, making them less useful than we would like. Although the brass buckles are beautiful, we didn't get the hang of the clasp that closes the lid of the camera bag and ended up leaving it unclasped. Despite its minor flaws, those looking for a small, luxury sling camera bag will love the fashion and function of the Bowery.
Why You Should Trust Us
Our team of professional photographers, Laura and Jason, took the lead on our sling camera bag review. Combined they have over 25 years of experience torturing cameras and bags from the city streets to desolate landscapes. Our lead tester, Jason, worked in one of the busiest photography rental houses in Los Angeles and estimates he's packed camera bags well over 4000 times. Over that time, he honed in on what goes into a great camera bag and where others tend to fail. We've taken those years of experience and implemented those lessons in our real world and controlled testing of each model.
We tested each bag head to head, scoring and ranking them within our testing metrics. The metrics we tested were comfort, ease of access, capacity, and how they stood up against the elements, among many other factors. To ensure accurate results, each bag faced the same tests in the same conditions.
Analysis and Test Results
Each sling was put through the same tests in the same conditions to evaluate them on our metrics. Below are the top products in each metric.
How comfortable a bag will be is both body-dependent and subjective. To best account for that in our testing, we had people with different body types test and give feedback on each bag. We walked 1.2 miles on the same course of pavement and trails with each kit loaded to full capacity to see how comfortable each model is while carrying the amount of gear it's designed for. All three of our top bags scored the same for comfort.
The Domke F-5XB and the ONA Bowery felt identical while wearing them, to the point where we did another test walk with both bags on to see if we could feel a difference — and we didn't. They are both beautifully balanced for small camera kits, and we wouldn't mind wearing either of these bags all day.
The The Peak Design Everyday Sling 10L we found to be a good compromise between size and comfort; big enough to carry what we need for a diverse day of photography but not so big as to be unwieldy and uncomfortable. This model carries tight to your body and feels agile, contributing to its comfort.
We buy and carry camera bags for one reason — to take pictures! With that in mind, accessing the camera is of the utmost importance. We wanted to determine how fast and easy it is to get to your camera while keeping everything else secure in your bag. With a stopwatch, we timed how long it took to complete common transitions. Specifically, we measured how long it took to switch from carrying the bag in transport to getting the camera out and the bag resecured.
At 5 seconds, the Domke was the fastest. This is due to its large size and the simplicity of the velcro closure. With only two items at your fingertips, you don't need to think much about what to take out of the bag. We love the multiple ways this bag can be closed, from fully zipped up and velcro flap closed to having both the velcro flap open and the bag unzipped. We tested this bag with the velcro flap down, but with the zipper unzipped.
The surprise of this test is just how well the Tenba DNA 15 fared. We assumed that the bigger bag was going to be less nimble, but that was proved wrong with a time of 6 seconds. The large zipper located on the top lid allows fast access to gear. The access zipper and placement of the camera promote fast deployment and is generally faster when located in the center of the pack.
Being just over a second slower with a similar design and size to the Domke, it's no surprise that the ONA Bowery is nipping at its heels. We attribute this fast time to its simple, user-friendly design with only one buckle and flap between you and your gear. The slower time can be associated with the beautiful brass buckle. That brass buckle is protected by a leather strap that you must navigate to unclasp the bag and open it. In daily use, we found ourselves ignoring that latch altogether, closing the top lid but not buckling it. When this tactic is employed, this bag is just as quick as the Domke.
Capacity helps define the uses a bag is suitable for. Ultimately, capacity is a straightforward metric — we are simply looking to see how much a given bag will hold. We looked at capacity from three perspectives: camera gear, accessories, and non-photographic gear. Those three aspects combined give us our overall score. Our testers had different ideas of what they were looking for with capacity, and the same is certainly true for you. One of our testers had this to say, "It's a little weird, but if the bag doesn't have a water bottle pocket, it's a deal-breaker." So keep in mind what you are looking for specifically and let that influence your decision.
As far as sling bags go, the Tenba DNA 15 falls into and wins the "everything but the kitchen sink" category. With considerably more room than its next competitor, the DNA 15 was the clear winner. It offers tons of space dedicated for your gear, two water bottle pockets, a spot for your laptop and a large tablet, and a mind-boggling amount of organization pockets. If you are looking for a high capacity sling bag, look no further.
The Peak Design Everyday Messenger is a great size for taking to the office and bringing a camera and a couple of lenses as well. It also does well on more photo-dedicated missions, holding one camera with a medium lens attached, two more small or medium lenses, and one large lens.
We found the Peak Design Everyday Sling 10L to be a perfect size for a day out shooting. It is big enough to hold your essential gear and has extra room to stash essentials for getting some work done at a coffee shop. While not big enough to hold all of our professional photographer's gear, this bag made us consider what we put in it, and we like that quality. Although you can squeeze a 13" laptop in it, we don't recommend it.
Our durability testing was targeted toward a few critical aspects. The first aspect is an indication of the lifespan of each bag. We looked for signs of premature wear, materials used, and the construction techniques employed. Our second aspect is how well a bag will protect your camera from daily life. Can it handle moisture? How well is padded? The results were close in the top three.
Edging out the competition is the Tenba DNA. Using durable materials with attention to construction, we were impressed with the overall build quality of this bag. It also performed very well in our rain stress testing. What made this bag a step ahead for us was its included rain cover. That small feature is much appreciated and not something offered by any other bag we tested.
A close contender was the Peak Design Everyday Sling. With a streamlined and straightforward design realized with top-notch materials, there is little room to fault this bag on build quality. That simple design leaves less moving parts to break. We love the hydrophobic zippers and durable shell materials that were wonderful at keeping the rain at bay.
Just one step back from the Everyday Sling is another bag from Peak Design, this time the Everyday Messenger 15. Like its sister product, this bag uses excellent materials that show no sign of slowing down any time soon. It also has hydrophobic zippers that do well at shedding water. This bag comes in slightly lower because it does not close entirely, like the Everyday Sling, leaving a higher chance for moisture to sneak in the bag.
You've worked hard to acquire your photographic gear so you can get out and shoot. The wrong bag can deter you from doing that, so make sure to invest in the right camera bag for you! We hope our testing results have helped you find a bag that fits your needs and will serve you well for years to come.
— Jason Peters