We bought the 9 most compelling crochet kits available today and tested them head-to-head to help you find the best. Our in-house experts made thousands of stitches and multiple projects, rating and ranking the comfort and ease of crocheting with the included hooks. We also looked at the included accessories, directions, and patterns to pick which kit truly had it all. Check out our comprehensive review to see which is the best option for beginners, which is the best all-in-one kit out there, and which is best for crafters on a budget.We've tested a variety of products for the home crafters and hobbyists out there, from sewing machines to home brewing kits.
Our Top Picks
Looking for a crotchet kit that's the cream of the crop? Well, we think the Inscraft 40 Acrylic Yarn Kit is hard to beat, particularly if you are looking to make amigurumi (stuffed animals) or other small projects. This kit includes a good spread of smaller aluminum hooks with slide-on rubber grips that make them considerably more ergonomic and comfortable. The 9 hooks, along with the included accessories (stitch markers, pins, measuring tape, scissors, stitch holder, row counter, and more) all fit in a smaller zippered hard case for easy transport. This case then fits in a zippered cube with 40 small skeins of 100% acrylic yarn in various colors. We are impressed overall with how the hooks feel to crochet with and love that everything you need to get started on your next crochet project is all included.
However, this kit is primarily geared towards making smaller items, with 6mm being the largest hook included. You also don't get too much yarn of any one color, with a single smaller stuffed animal practically exhausting an entire skein. Also, there aren't any instructions or patterns included, so a total beginner will have to find some additional materials to get started, though there are plenty of free tutorials and patterns out there. All in all, we think this is a premium crochet kit and highly recommend it to both beginners and experts, particularly those looking to get into amigurumi.
If you have plenty of your own yarn and are just looking for a top-notch kit with all the tools you need to start crocheting, then we think the BeCraftee Crochet Hook Set is one of the best options on the market today. The included hooks for this kit are quite comfortable to crochet with, as they have larger molded ergonomic grips that reduce pressure points and hot spots. The hooks are deep enough to easily grab all the piles of the yarn and have enough of a point that you can work them through tighter stitches without issues. This kit also includes most of the other tools you might need, like stitch markers, a stitch counter, keepers, folding scissors, measuring tape, hook gauge/ruler, and large-eye tapestry needles for weaving in ends, and a convenient zippered storage case.
We found a few flaws with the BeCraftee Crochet Hook Set. The largest hook is only 6mm, which will generally limit you to small to medium yarns — this is definitely not the kit if you are looking to make those quick 1-hour projects with chunky or super bulky yarns. We also preferred the metal tapestry needles over the plastic ones included with this kit, as their increased rigidity made weaving in ends or embroidering details much easier, as well as being overall more durable. Along with the lack of yarn, this crochet kit also doesn't include any instructions or patterns, so it might not be the best choice for a total beginner looking for an all-in-one option. However, we highly recommend it to anyone looking for a top-tier hook and accessory set.
If you are looking for an inexpensive crochet hook set that is comfortable to use, we think the WooCrafts Large-Eye Blunt Needle Kit is a great option. This bare-bones set includes 9 hooks with molded rubber grips, metal tapestry needles, and some plastic stitch markers, all in a flowery zippered soft case. We like that this kit has just the essentials — minus scissors — and is much more compact than some of the larger kits with zippered binder-style cases. We also found the molded rubber grips to be quite comfortable and easy to crochet with, eliminating hand cramps caused by the smaller aluminum hooks.
While we found these grips to be considerably more comfortable than a bare hook, some of the other ergonomic sets had slightly more rounded grips, making them more comfortable to use than these. This kit also doesn't include any patterns, instructions, or yarn, and the range of sizes is more suited to smaller projects, like amigurumi, beanies, or anything else that calls for a super bulky yarn. But for the price, this kit is simple and gets the job done for your smaller crochet projects.
If you are looking to get started with crochet and trying to spend as little as possible, we think it's worth checking out the BCMRUN Crochet Hooks Set. This inexpensive set includes 14 aluminum hooks, encompassing a much larger size range than many of the other sets and allowing you to tackle projects from the daintiest doily to a bulky blanket. We also like that this set includes a convenient travel case, a measuring tape, stitch markers, and some metal tapestry needles for weaving in your ends.
However, we found that these are significantly less comfortable and more difficult to crochet with. These hooks can definitely lead to hand cramps in our experience, and the shorter ones can cause a bit of a pressure point on your palm when crocheting using a knife grip. The hooks are also on the shallower side. Moreover, this kit lacks yarn, patterns, and instructions, so you will need to factor that into the cost when considering this kit. If you are looking for a kit that has a low cost and allows for a wide range of projects, this is the versatile kit to meet your needs. Unfortunately, you can probably expect to outgrow the BCMRUN hooks in favor of some more ergonomic models if you seriously get into the craft.
If you're new to crocheting and searching for a kit with plenty of patterns and instructions, we think the Mira Handcrafts 24 Acrylic Yarn Skeins set is your best bet. In addition to having all the materials and tools you might need, Mira also has a small library of free eBooks covering everything from types of stitches to sample patterns. You get a wide variety of colors with the included yarn, and we found it to be some of the highest quality yarn of the kits we tested.
However, this kit is a little light when it comes to accessories, only including a pair of aluminum hooks and a handful of large-eye needles. The hooks aren't our favorites in terms of comfort, and we wish the kit offered a few more sizes that would support a wider range of projects. Most likely, you will eventually outgrow this kit and need to get a larger range of sizes. However, we strongly feel the Mira crochet kit, with its high-quality yarn and the included resource library, is a great option for beginners, and we readily recommend it.
If you're a beginner looking for a starter kit, the Knit Picks Beginner Dishcloth Kit is definitely worth considering. This kit includes a 6mm wooden crochet hook, a printed instruction book, three skeins of variegated yarn, and a single metal tapestry needle. The booklet features plenty of pictures and starts right from the basics, assuming that the user is a total novice. We found the larger wooden hook to not only be visually appealing but to be quite comfortable to crochet with as well.
The yarn included in this kit is on the thin side — just a bit less bulky than a typical worsted weight, in our opinion. This can make it difficult for beginners to get their stitch tension right, as it's very easy to tighten the loops too much. The yarn also tends to grab a bit more with a wooden hook than an aluminum one. Despite this issue, the Knit Picks is one of our all-time favorite kits for beginners, and we think it's a good way to get into the hobby.
If you have ever been looking for a way to combine fiber arts and fan art, then the Harry Potter Crochet Kit is a great option, and makes a great gift to boot. This cute kit includes just about everything you might need to crochet a tiny Harry and Dobby with his sock. The included book has very thorough and clear directions, with patterns for plenty of other witches and wizards if you are willing to supply your own yarn once you have exhausted the included materials.
While the amigurumis produced are undeniably adorable, they also are quite intricate and complex. We could definitely see a novice crocheter becoming quite frustrated with this kit, especially with the included novelty hook. While the plastic hook fashioned to look like Harry's wand is a fun idea, we found it to be much less comfortable and much harder to crochet with due to its compliant nature. As the wand also doesn't seem to have convinced the yarn to crochet itself — albeit with our admittedly limited knowledge of incantations — we would suggest using more traditional hooks for this somewhat complicated project. That said, it's a great kit for an intermediate/advanced crocheter who wants to add some magic to their lives or give a fun gift to a crochet-adept friend, but, as a standalone kit, it's definitely far from our favorite.
The 4M Easy-To-Do Crochet Kit is an all-in-one kit for your kids to try out crocheting. This kit includes a pair of stubby plastic hooks, a yarn needle, several small skeins of yarn, and complete instructions for starting and a few projects. We like that the patterns are aimed at total beginners — along with flipped diagrams for left-handers — and that they give you some creative freedom when it comes to putting your own twist on the projects.
However, we do think that this kit is far from perfect. The plastic hooks are very stubby and can be quite uncomfortable to crochet with. The tip of the hooks also had a slight bit of flashing that can catch on the yarn. This, combined with the included yarn's propensity to split, made for a frustrating experience. This is an inexpensive kit that gives some exposure to crocheting and can get you through a project or two, but we think it's going to be outgrown very quickly.
The Darn Good Yarn DIY Cactus Kit comes with everything you need to make a trio of adorable amigurumi cacti, perfect for those that perpetually forget to water their desk plants. This kit includes both knitting and crochet patterns for all three cacti, as well as wooden knitting needles and a plastic crochet hook, and a tapestry needle. It also has all the different yarn you might need, as well as polyester stuffing.
Unfortunately, we found the included plastic hook to be so flimsy that it was almost impossible to use. Also, the cacti patterns very much depend on you having a decent amount of crochet experience under your belt, and we would strongly discourage a beginner from choosing this kit. It's also not particularly versatile, as you aren't going to be able to do much beyond the three projects without getting more yarn and more tools since the included hook must be upgraded. It might be a nice option if you are an established crocheter with a limited selection of colors on hand, but we would suggest an alternative kit to just about everyone.
Why You Should Trust Us
Austin Palmer and David Wise take the lead for our crochet kit review. Both are avid DIY'ers and have reviewed hundreds of products together. David crocheted his first beanie over 17 years ago and hasn't stopped since. He regularly makes projects from beanies to blankets and has an Etsy store that sells science-themed amigurumi. Austin is a beginner crocheter, allowing him to rate and score these kits from a novice perspective.
Throughout this review, we made thousands of stitches, completing a plethora of different projects. We compared the ergonomics and how comfortable it is to crochet with the included hooks, as well as the quality of the included materials and instructions. We spent dozens of hours with these products, comparing their performance side-by-side to help you find the perfect crochet kit, regardless if you are a total expert or a complete beginner.
Analysis and Test Results
We split our testing process into multiple weighted metrics — Hook Quality and Comfort, Beginner-Friendliness, Versatility, and Included Accessories — with a side-by-side comparison of the standout performers in each metric discussed in the sections below.
Hook Quality and Comfort
First and foremost, we compared the ergonomics of the included hooks, as well as how easy they are to crochet with. We also took into account the number of hooks and the range of sizes included with each kit.
Overall, we liked the hooks from the Inscraft 40 Acrylic Yarn Kit and the BeCraftee Crochet Hook Set, with the WooCrafts Large-Eye Blunt Needle Kit just trailing them slightly. The Inscraft hooks and the BeCraftee hooks both have molded rubber grips that make them considerably more comfortable to use than a typical crochet hook. These hooks are pointy enough to poke through tighter stitches and are deep enough to easily grab all of the yarn without splitting piles off.
We found the grips work well with either a knife or pencil grip and, as a result, are some of our favorite products to use. Both the Inscraft and the BeCraftee include 9 hooks ranging in size from 2.25mm to 6mm but have different intervals for the smaller hooks. The Inscraft includes a 2mm, 2.5mm, 3mm, 3.5mm, 4mm, 4.5mm, 5mm, 5.5mm, and a 6mm hook, while the BeCraftee has a 2.25mm, 2.75mm, 3.25mm, 3.5mm, 4mm, 4.5mm, 5mm, 5.5mm, and a 6mm hook.
The WooCrafts Large-Eye crochet hooks also have an ergonomic rubber grip, but we found them slightly less comfortable to hold than both the BeCraftee and the Inscraft. We do like that the WooCrafts hooks have a longer neck, but the blunter tip can be a bit more difficult to get through tighter stitches. The WooCrafts Large-Eye kit also includes 9 hooks that are identical to the sizes included in the Inscraft kit. Finally, we found the 6mm wooden hook included with the Knit Picks Learn to Crochet Kit to be quite comfortable to hold — and it looks great, too.
However, the wooden Knit Picks hook can be a bit more difficult for a beginner to use, as it takes some time to get used to the deeper hook and the sharper edge, making it much easier to split the piles of the yarn apart.
Both the Mira Handcrafts and the BCMRUN hooks are standard aluminum hooks and are about the same when it comes to comfort and quality. These hooks crochet well, hooking yarn easily and offering a low-friction surface for the yarn with their anodized aluminum coatings. Unfortunately, we found hand cramps and hot spots to be much more prevalent when using these hooks, particularly with the smaller sizes.
We do favor the BCMRUN hooks over the Mira Handcrafts, as it includes far more hooks. The Mira kit only includes a 4.5mm and a 5.5mm hook, while the BCMRUN includes one of the largest ranges of sizes out of any of the kits we reviewed, covering 2mm - 10mm with its 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 4.5, 5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 8, 9, and 10mm hooks.
The 4M Easy-To-Do Crochet Kit comes next on our list, having the worst hooks that we felt were actually functional. It has a pair of stubby plastic 8mm hooks, but we didn't find them comfortable to hold or easy to crochet with. They had some sharp edges and residual mold flashing that would catch and split the yarn, and the shorter length definitely led to some hand cramps and odd pressure points when used by an adult. However, they could be alright for a child or someone with very petite hands after you rounded off the sharp edges.
Bringing up the back of the group, we were very much not fans of the included hooks with the Harry Potter Crochet Kit and the Darn Good Yarn Cactus Kit. The wand-shaped hook with the Harry Potter Kit is actually quite comfortable to hold, but we found it funky and difficult to crochet with, opting to swap to an aluminum hook very early on for those projects. The minuscule hook included with the Cactus Kit is incredibly bendy, and we found it to be almost impossible to crochet with, again opting for a more traditional hook for the completion of our cactus.
For this metric, we looked at each of these kits from the perspective of a beginner. We looked at the quality of the included instructions, the difficulty of the pattern, and if you needed any tools or materials beyond what is included in the kit.
If you are a total novice, then we think the Mira Handcrafts 24 Acrylic Skeins is a great option. Of the kits that include yarn, we think the Mira had some of the highest quality yarn and was least prone to splitting in our tests and alleviating one of the most common sources of frustration for beginners. Mira also provides a small library of free eBooks with patterns and directions to get you started. The included hooks, needles, and yarn also fit in a resealable case, and the only other tools you might need is a pair of scissors for cutting the yarn if you don't want to just snap it. It doesn't have any stitch markers, but you can just use a scrap of another color of yarn to make do.
We also think the Knit Picks Learn To Crochet Beginner Kit is another good option for those just starting. This kit includes a very thorough written instruction manual, making it a good option for anyone who would rather read physical manuals over digital ones. The pattern for the dishcloth is very simple and a great novice project. This kit has everything you need to make multiple dishcloths, but the yarn/pattern combo can make it a little difficult to get the tension right at first.
The 4M Easy-To-Do Crochet Kit also contains a full set of printed instructions for a handful of different projects and includes a pair of crochet hooks and a needle. The instructions are quite comprehensive but can be a bit hard to follow, as you need to jump around to different sets of steps depending on what you are trying to make. We don't think the patterns are too difficult, but we found the included hook and yarn make crocheting so difficult that it can be very frustrating.
We think the Inscraft 40 Acrylic Yarn Kit is the next best kit for beginners. While this kit doesn't come with any patterns, it includes everything else a beginner might need — yarn, needles, stitch markers, and a solid assortment of comfortable hooks. The included yarn is a great choice for a beginner, and as there are so many free resources and beginner patterns available online, the lack of instructions isn't too big of a roadblock.
The BeCraftee, WooCrafts, and the BCMRUN are next when it comes to being beginner-friendly. These kits have all the tools someone starting might need but lack both instructions and yarn. Yarn is fairly inexpensive, and these kits have everything a beginner might need, but they are admittedly far from an all-in-one kit.
At the back of the group is the Harry Potter and Darn Good Yarn DIY Cactus kits, as both are poor choices for beginners.
While we will admit that these kits include everything you need — instructions, hooks, yarn, and accessories — the patterns are quite difficult for a novice. These kits are great for an experienced crocheter who wants a self-contained project, but there are much better options out there for beginners.
For our versatility metric, we compared the kits on how soon you might outgrow them or need to purchase additional tools or materials. The Inscraft 40 Acrylic Yarn Kit takes the lead in this metric, offering more than enough yarn and a variety of different hook sizes for plenty of projects to keep just about anyone occupied for a long time. However, the yarn skeins are a bit small, so you will probably need to find other yarn if you are looking for a large monochromatic project.
We think the Mira Handcrafts 24 Acrylic Yarn Skeins is also another very versatile kit — just behind the Inscraft. It includes a bit less yarn and only two sizes of crochet hooks, so you will be a bit more limited in both the number of projects and the variety you can take on before needing more yarn or hooks but still has more than enough for many hours of crocheting.
The hook-only kits are next, with the BCMRUN being just a bit more versatile than the WooCrafts or the BeCraftee. It has a larger range of sizes, allowing you to tackle some quick crochet projects with chunky or super bulky yarn that wouldn't be possible with the BeCraftee or WooCrafts set. However, all three have a large range of hook sizes for a bunch of different projects — as long as you buy the yarn for them.
The Knit Picks Beginner Dishcloth Kit is designed for making dishcloths, but you do have enough extra yarn that you could make a few other items to match, like a placemat or coaster. This is followed by the 4M Easy-To-Do Crochet Kit. This kit comes with a small amount of yarn, but we would imagine most people would quickly be in the market for not only more yarn but also better hooks.
At the back of the group when it comes to versatility, the Harry Potter Crochet Kit and the Darn Good Yarn DIY Cactus Kit are essentially designed for completing the included patterns, and that's about it. The Harry Potter Kit offers a handful of other patterns, but you'll need to purchase additional yarn if you want to create more magical beings beyond Harry and Dobby. We again feel that most people would be in the market for more yarn and more hooks rather quickly with these kits.
We also rated and scored the different non-crochet hook accessories included with each kit. The Inscraft and BeCraftee take the lead, both having a measuring tape, stitch markers, yarn needles, ruler/gauge chart, scissors, stitch holders, and a counter. However, we think the Inscraft has just a slight edge, as it also includes some knitting accessories, metal yarn needles compared to plastic, and multiple styles of stitch markers.
The WooCrafts kit offered some plastic stitch markers and a variety of metal yarn needles in addition to the hooks. The remaining kits are all fairly limited when it comes to accessories, only including some yarn needles for finishing. However, the Harry Potter Crochet Kit also includes some safety eyes and embroidery floss for your first two projects.
We hope this comprehensive side-by-side comparison has been helpful in your crusade for a new crochet kit, whether you are an expert looking for an advanced project or a complete beginner looking for an all-in-one option.
— David Wise and Austin Palmer
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More