Food Storage Containers
The USA made Rubbermaid Brilliance food storage set will open up more refrigerator and cupboard space as the set stacks modularly in use and nests when unneeded. The lids create a watertight seal with two easy to open hinged snaps. When left opened, the snaps expose vents that promote cooling while the lid is in place. This set of containers covers a wide variety of sizes that allow one to use both large or small storage containers while remaining easily stackable. Moreover, the transparent plastic allows one to quickly identify the food they are after.
While we like the crystal clear plastic of the Brilliance containers, we are a bit concerned that small scratches were noticeable after just a few washes. Moreover, the vessel retained a light odor after tests with odoriferous foods. Yet, the Brilliance line offers superior durability for those traveling or commuting with meals. When it does come time to replace one of these containers, the company has a recycling program that promises an afterlife for products that are no longer usable.
The Newfit reusable pinch lock bags are a great substitute for the throwaway variety. The transparent material and heavy-duty zipper provide good visibility of the bag's contents and a complete seal that you can expect not to break, even if put under considerable pressure. The materials are free from the most chemicals of concern such as BPA and PVC. Additionally, the silicone stretch lids included provide an easy transition from single-use plastic wrap.
As with all the bags we tested, the Newfit was susceptible to staining and lingering odor after storing acidic or oily foods. These bags did not present as much discoloration and odors as others in the class, yet they remained tinted after our tomato sauce test. Given the likelihood of staining, we advise discretion with the foods you choose to store in these bags. As a side note, we found the stretchy silicone covers that are part of the set to be really useful for quickly sealing cans, jars, and even bowls for a night or two in the fridge.
The C Crest food storage set includes 10 glass vessels (5 x 1040 mL, 5 x 370 mL) that are hermetically sealed with high-quality plastic lids and hinged snaps. The silicone gaskets housed in the lids are also removable, making deep cleaning much easier. What makes this design so effective is that the moving parts on the units (i.e. the snaps) are not prone to fatigue as is the case with the one-piece lids of the lower-quality models. As such, our testers felt confident that these lids could be secured indefinitely without concern for failure.
The design of the C Crest containers leaves little room for critique. Yet, it should be noted that the size of these vessels is not suited for large meal storage. Unfortunately, C Crest does not provide customer service either. This means there's no practical way to replace lids and vessels if they are damaged or lost. A final concern for those with smaller kitchens is that the units do not nest well for storage. As a result, the containers will eat-up a fair amount of cupboard real estate. That said, this food storage system is durable, stain/odor-resistant, and the plastic is BPA-free. Lastly, the containers can be used as cookware (without lids) in both the microwave and oven.
If you have a big family and are trying to reduce the waste you drag out to the curb each week, the eoglo storage bags could be a welcomed addition to your kitchen. This 11-pack comes with 5 sandwich-sized units, 4 snack-sized units, and 2 gallon-sized bags that can accommodate watermelon and the like for family outings. The pinch lock zipper achieves a great seal and it is easy to release as well. Finally, the transparent plastic is durable and makes food identification a breeze.
As with all the bags in this review, the eoglo bags are susceptible to discoloration when oily or acidic foods are stored in them. Along with this discoloration often comes lingering smells. Yet, aside from having to be a little selective about what we stored in these bags, we had little to complain about with this cost-effective, reliable, and waste-reducing product.
Two of the more frustrating aspects of food storage sets are that the containers take up a lot of cupboard space and the lids get lost. The Joseph Joseph Nest Lock's design does much to address these issues by sizing the containers to fit together like Russian dolls and designing the lids to secure one to another in a tapering stack. The result is an extremely compact storage size that still provides tons of container space. On top of this standard-setting storage size to container ratio, these units boast hinged snap locks for maximum longevity.
While we love the Joseph Joseph's stacking method, plastic containers are far more susceptible to scratching, staining, and retaining food smells compared to their glass counterparts. It should be noted that the Nest Lock fared better than most plastic units in this regard. Yet, you should still be selective about what you put into the unit if they want to maintain its transparency. That said, we think those with limited kitchen space will find this sacrifice more than worth the cupboard real estate saved.
If you are moving through a lot of ingredients such as flour, then having bulk containers is the way to go. The Chef's Path's two 5.2-liter units offer wide openings for scooping out the contents and include measuring cups for this purpose. Their square shape means that they fit well in a cupboard or on a shelf. The 4-snap, water-tight lids also help to keep the contents fresh and dry. The transparent BPA free plastic makes it easy to identify the stored items. If you have two similar-looking staples, however, then make use of the marker and labels that are included with this set.
Although the size, shape, and seal on these containers leave little to gripe about, we are concerned about the long-term durability of the snaps securing the lids. Unlike some of the other containers in this review, the Chef's Path does not use hinges on their snaps. This means that a thin plastic strip prone to fatigue provides the movement needed for the snap to work. Additionally, the container itself is a bit thinner than we'd like. On the other hand, this thinness keeps them lightweight. The units are tapered to nest inside one another when being transported or not in use. All in all, these plastic containers offer a great alternative to single-use bags both for food freshness and environmental conscientiousness.
There's a lot to like about the Pyrex Simply Store set. What really distinguishes this storage system, however, is that Pyrex allows customers to replace lids or vessels individually on their website. Surprisingly, this is quite rare for a food storage company and speaks to the pride this American manufacturer takes in their products. This set is also one of the few that comes in both a multitude of sizes and shapes. Given that these containers are legitimate cookware, we found the option of making various-sized casseroles and lasagnas fun and practical for on the go meals.
The reason the Simply Store set didn't rate higher in our evaluation is that the lids are not watertight, and the vessels can't nest together for storage. That's it. So, if you're looking for a well-made product that doesn't stain or retain odors, look no further. As an additional consideration, the lack of moving parts in the lid design reduces potential points of failure.
Although there were several reusable bags in our testing group that seal with a slider-bar, the Leafy Home performed the best of the bunch. The wide bottom of these bags makes filling easy because they can stand on their own. This feature also makes them good for cooking applications such as sous vide, steaming, or reheating in hot water. The seal is watertight and, while the bags do hold stains, they are some of the more stain-resistant of the reusable bags.
Despite being more stain-resistant than the other food storage bags in our review, the Leafy Home still displayed discoloration and lingering food smells following our red sauce test. Exacerbating this issue is the cupped shape of the bag bottom which complicates cleaning. An additional concern is the closure mechanism. The plastic bar that slides across the silicone bag can be grabby and difficult to close, so we occasionally had to resort to wetting this bar for lubrication on the larger bags. That said, if you're storing liquid foods or using the bag as a piece of cookware, they're hard to beat.
Over the years the author has spent a lot of time in the kitchen with his grandmother. In recent years, he's noticed the increased difficulty that her hands have when opening jars or other sealed containers. When the OXO POP came across his desk, he immediately thought of how beneficial this system would be to her. These containers can open and completely seal with the push of a button. Having reviewed many products from OXO over the years, our team has come to expect high-quality manufacturing and elegant designs, and the POP series did not disappoint. The unique shapes, such as a spaghetti-sized model, and the crystal clear plastic will tempt you to leave them out on the counter as practical decorations.
The main reason this food storage set ended up at the bottom of our top-performers list is that there are only 5 containers in the set, and it is one of the more expensive products that we reviewed. Additionally, the plastic is prone to showing scratches. However, unlike the lower-end plastics used by some of the competition, these containers performed much like glass in the tomato sauce test, retaining no staining or odors after a quick cleaning in the sink. Finally, it's worth noting that OXO is a member of 1% For the Planet, the gold standard for environmental philanthropy, and any purchase contributes directly to this organization's programs.
Why You Should Trust Us
Senior Review Editor Nick Miley is an obsessive home cook who enjoys spending a Sunday afternoon cooking from scratch and storing up delicious meals for the workweek. He cut his teeth in the culinary business as a 16-year old prep cook for a busy riverside fish shack on Alaska's Kenai Peninsula. From then to now, Nick has tried out nearly every type of food container and knows a good product when he gets his hands on it. He has used this experience to research, buy, test, and rate kitchen products and share his findings with the general public.
To evaluate the quality and functionality of the food storage sets in this review we focused on the materials, sealing mechanism, and stackability, as well as stain and odor retention. Additionally, we looked at the economy of the products and how many containers each set includes. We also investigated the possibility of replacing the lids and vessels and the social responsibility practiced by the manufacturers. The latter assessment includes product end of life plans and additional philanthropic activities.
Did you know that you can bring your own food storage containers to stores with bulk offerings? It's true. Make sure the container is clean and put a piece of masking tape on the lid so a store clerk can mark the weight of the empty container(s). At checkout, the clerk can tare the weight of the container to calculate the weight of the food you selected. This practice can eliminate the use of disposable bags while reducing trips to the store.
Analysis and Test Results
Our evaluation of food storage sets began with discussions about common frustrations with these products. Not surprisingly, most people's complaints fell into just a few categories. The first were issues with the lid — primarily ineffective seals or closure failures. Discoloration of the materials and linger smells was another concern. Finally, cupboard stackability and the inevitable lost lid that can't be replaced were further complaints. Accordingly, we devised tests to investigate all of these issues. The following are the details of this evaluation, including which product performed the best, and why.
For a food container to work effectively, it must be able to seal. This is particularly true if the container is to be used for transporting food outside of the house. Except for the Pyrex Simply Store, all of the products reviewed here displayed excellent sealing. However, just because only one of these containers leaked water when inverted, shook, and squeezed, does not mean that the methods for achieving an effective seal were equivalent.
We favored containers like the Rubbermaid Brilliance that have proper hinges connecting their snap wings to the lid rather than those with a thin piece of plastic like the Chef's Path. The latter design is common and seems destined to wear and fail in time. As for the bags, we preferred the zip or pinch lock models such as the Newfit because the seal is easy to make and the audible snap at the end confirms it has occurred. Conversely, the slider bar models were less to our liking. The main reason for this is the sticky nature of the silicone bag. The wider the opening of the bag, the more of a problem we had with them.
As a final consideration, we found that we preferred the containers that incorporate removable gaskets. The C Crest as well as the Chef's Path provide this feature, which makes cleaning that much easier.
Stains and Odor
If you've ever reheated spaghetti or lasagna in a plastic container, then you have a good idea of the orangish hue that a well-used food container can acquire over time. Given this disagreeable, though all too common outcome, we devised what we call the red sauce test.
The test was simple. We heated store-bought tomato sauce and poured it into the containers under review. We allowed the sauce to cool and then stuck the containers with the sauce in the refrigerator overnight. We then cleaned the containers in the sink. Because this test was conducted on just one of the units in each set, we were able to perform side-by-side, before-and-after comparison for coloration and smell.
It should come as no surprise that the glass models such as the C Crest and the Pyrex fared best, while plastic products like the Chef's Path and the Newfit bags were left colored and odoriferous. What was surprising and impressive is that some plastic models like the Rubbermaid and the OXO rendered results akin to glass models. Now that's some high-end plastic.
This broad category of assessment covers product details such as stackability, the number, and the volume of containers in each set, the construction material, and whether they are BPA free. We also looked at where the products are made, whether the lids and vessels are easily replaceable, and if the company has a product end of life policy.
Rubbermaid, OXO, and Pyrex made good showings in this analysis. While these products don't nest as well as others, their manufacturing is of high quality. Rubbermaid is entirely made in the USA and they have partnered with TerraCycle to provide an end of life option for customers that have worn out their containers. Similarly, Pyrex manufactures all of their lids in the USA and much of their vessels as well. Replacement lids and vessels are available for purchase should you lose or break them. Finally, OXO is a member of the 1% for the Planet organization which is arguably the premier environmental nonprofit.
All the containers in our review are BPA free. As for stackability, the Joseph Joseph are head and shoulders above the rest as the entire set can fit into its largest container. The C Crest glass containers come in a set of 10 and the eoglo reusable bags come in a pack of 11. At 5.2-liters, the Chef's Path bulk containers are among the biggest we've reviewed.
This review of food storage sets tried to cover everything you might want to know before purchase. Our investigation ranged from the quality and type of seal used to secure the lid to the container, stain, and odor resistance, as well as an assessment of the user's experience. This last topic looks at the construction materials, the companies' conscientiousness including waste management, environmental policies, and the availability of replacement parts. Finally, we looked at space-saving products, set counts, and volume. In a fast-paced world, it's nice to have good food ready to go without creating any unnecessary waste. We hope that this article will aid you in that effort.
— Nick Miley