We designed all of our testing metrics in order to determine which consumer drone is best able to easily and reliably capture high-quality footage. To do this we purchased nine of the most popular amateur models on the market and flew them side by side through a series of exhaustive tests.
To test video quality we flew all of our testing models along similar paths at similar times of the day to ensure that lighting conditions remained fairly consistent. We made sure these flight paths included both long, smooth panning shots and some tight twist and turns. We then closely evaluated the resulting footage for a number of factors: how stable the camera remained through all the maneuvers, the resolution and color quality of the images, and if the propellers ever impeded on the camera's view. We also paid attention to things like whether pointing the camera at the sun affected color saturation. We made all of these comparisons side by side on large, high definition monitors that allowed us to open multiple videos in the same viewing environment.
We evaluated flight performance flying each drone extensively. We took each one on long out and back routes, put them through the twisting and turning of following mountain bikers and frolicking dogs, and made sure they could stay steady when hovering close to the ground. This gave us a clear idea of the responsiveness of each model. We paid particular attention to how stable each model was during takeoff and landing, as these are some of the most accident-prone points in every flight. We also specifically tested each model's specific autonomous flight features. Since most of these features are designed to make capturing certain types of footage easier, we evaluated these features both in how smooth the flight appeared when we used them, and how good the resulting footage looked. For example, orbit point of interest features are meant to yield a nice circular panning shot centered around a particular point. We scored these features based on how reliably and steadily the flight pattern was executed, and how smooth and focused the resulting footage looked. We also made sure to evaluate the dependability of each model's automatic return to home function, though we would not recommend using such a feature unless it is a last resort (ie. you've lost sight of or contact with the drone).
Ease of Use
In assessing ease of use we considered the amount of effort required between opening the box and getting the drone in the air. This included initial setup of the drone, attaching rotors, downloading any required applications, and pairing the drone, controller, and smart device. We also closely evaluated the user interface on each controller and any menu options that appear on the connected smart device display. We were looking for joysticks that felt solid and provided good tactile feedback, and on-screen menus that allowed easy navigation of in-flight functions. After many hours of flying each one of these models, our testers were able to make meaningful comparisons.
We tested the quality of each video downlink by completing a 3000-foot flight with each of the models we tested (an exception was made for models with shorter ranges). This distance pushed the range of the drones towards the outer edge of what can be considered reasonable and safe flight. Throughout these flights we closely inspected the video downlinks, noting how clear each one was, if there were any decreases in quality during the flight and if there were any glitches or loss of picture.
To evaluate portability we brought the drones on as many trips as we could. This varied from roadside car camping to backcountry ski tours. In addition to subjective evaluation, we measured and weighed each drone with any included case and controller. We noted which ones were feasible for packing into a backpack and how susceptible to any damage they would be in a full bag. Some models can be tossed into a bag as an afterthought, while others can only be carried in large cases that are hardly portable. Many new models have been designed for travel and some of the best cameras are found on drones that fit into an average day pack.