Best Running Headphones of 2020
Of all the earbuds we tested, the Jaybird Vista was the most universally lauded for its comfort and stability. All of our testers, regardless of ear size or shape, were treated to a fit that felt comfortable over multiple hours of wear and stayed secure even when tired legs led to heavy strides. Perhaps most importantly, the impressively light weight all but eliminates the annoying tugging sensation that can accompany running with buds in your ears. The IPX7 waterproof rating means these buds can survive total submersion in a meter of water for half an hour, so you don't have to worry when dark clouds appear midway through your run. To top it all off the Jaybird Vista sounds fantastic. It is able to excellently render everything from powerful bass tracks to keep you motivated through sets of sprint intervals, to crystal clear podcasts and audiobooks for enlightenment during your cool down.
Unfortunately the best running earbuds on the market come at a correspondingly high price — the Jaybird Vista is one of the pricier models on this list. However, if you're willing to pay a bit extra for the best of the best, the Jaybird Vista offers field-leading and uncompromising performance.
Read review: Jaybird Vista
You don't need to spend top dollar to add an enjoyable soundtracked to your runs, and no earbuds prove that point better than the JBL Reflect Mini 2. These buds manage to provide great sound quality as well as impressive comfort and stability at a fraction of the cost of most of the truly wireless models. An IPX5 water resistance rating means they can also shrug off rainstorms and excessive sweat with ease. In our tests the battery lasted an impressive 11.5 hours on a single charge, meaning they can likely last through your next ultra-marathon (or just forgive the fact that you forgot to charge the buds after your last run).
The biggest downside to this budget option is the wire that connects the two buds and drapes behind your neck. This wire tends to bounce a bit as you run, dropping onto your neck with every stride. Though the sensation this causes is minimal, it is noticeable, and might be annoying to some. Additionally, though most of our testers easily found a comfortable fit, some with larger ears struggled to find an earpiece/ear fin combo that was both comfortable and stable. Still, the JBL Reflect Mini 2 will offer most people great all-around performance at a competitive price.
Read review: JBL Reflect Mini 2
Running in cities presents multiple potential hazards in the form of cars, busses, trains, and distracted pedestrians. Plugging your ears with earbuds can make you oblivious to these dangers. The AfterShokz Air is one of the few devices on the market that offers a reasonable compromise between no music and significant hearing impairment. It does this by vibrating sound into your ears through your cheekbones, leaving your ears totally uncovered and able to hear the world around you. We personally felt much more aware of our surroundings while listening to music with the AfterShokz Air compared to traditional earbuds. They manage to do all this while fitting comfortably and stably, no matter the size or shape of your ears.
It turns out that cheekbones have largely evolved to better take a punch (no really, look it up) rather than to act as musical instruments. Therefore, we found the bone-conduction style of these headphones to generally produce a shallower and more tinny sound than traditional earbuds. Also, since the headphones sit on top of your ears, they sometimes end up jockeying for position with the temples of sunglasses. Despite these drawbacks, we still think the AfterShokz Air offers a fantastic entertainment solution for those situations when covering your ears isn't prudent.
Read review: AfterShokz Air
We've often found ourselves cranking the volume of our earbuds to uncomfortable levels to sufficiently drown out the din of the gym while we run on the treadmill, only to leave with our ears ringing. Even when running on home treadmills we've committed the same sin in order to block out the sound of the motor bouncing off the walls. This is where the Apple AirPods Pro excel. They offer the best active noise cancellation of all the athletically inclined earbuds we've tested, allowing you to block out the noise of the gym or treadmill and listen to your music at a reasonable volume. This noise cancellation is backed up by great sound, intuitive controls, and a comfortable fit.
Unfortunately, this noise cancellation technology comes at a price — the AirPods Pro are some of the most expensive earbuds on the market. Additionally, they don't offer any sort of ear fins or ear hooks to provide extra stability. They are light enough, and, given the three size options included, the silicone earpieces fit securely enough that our testers didn't have any stability issues. However, some would have appreciated the extra peace of mind that ear fins provide, especially considering how expensive the buds are. But if you often feel like you've just left a concert when you step off the treadmill, the Apple AirPods Pro can provide excellent sound while protecting your ears.
Read review: Apple AirPods Pro
A bit of stress can often creep in when running with an expensive pair of truly wireless earbuds. If you can't shake images of your pricey buds falling out and being lost to a sewer drain or mud puddle, the Beats by Dre Powerbeats Pro is for you. The over-ear hooks of these buds make them incredibly stable and downgrade one of them falling out to a near impossibility. That extra scaffolding also allows for slightly beefier technology, providing these buds with some of the best bass and longest battery life of all the models we've tested.
Apart from a large price tag, our biggest complaint with the Powerbeats Pro is that the over-ear hook can get in the way of sunglasses. Additionally, while we found them comfortable for most runs, they started to feel a bit cumbersome when worn for more than two hours. This somewhat negates the benefit of their long battery life. Still, for those that value stability over all else, the Powerbeats Pro are the clear choice.
Read review: Beats by Dre Powerbeats Pro
If you want the added stability of over-ear hooks but don't want to pay top dollar, the Beats by Dr. Dre Powerbeats3 is the perfect choice. These wired Bluetooth earbuds provide rotund and immersive sound, a long battery life, and the added security of over-ear hooks for less than most of its truly wireless competitors.
Like all over-ear models, the Powerbeats3 can sometimes get in the way of sunglasses. Additionally, the wire that drapes behind the neck tends to bounce when running, creating a sensation that is usually easily ignored but can sometimes get irritating. However, these are only minor drawbacks for those seeking extra stability at less than top-dollar.
Read review: Beats by Dr. Dre Powerbeats3
The Jabra Elite 75t offers impressive sound quality, managing to throw down powerful yet well-defined bass notes while maintaining clarity through the higher registers — a rarity in the world of earbuds. You can also get 11 hours of playback before having to put the buds back into their charging case, making them perfect for long runs or for pulling double duty on long flights or bus rides. The IP55 dust and water resistance rating means they can easily shake off sudden rainstorms and being dropped in the dirt.
The big caveat to the Jabra Elite 75t is the fit. These buds tend to be quite polarizing, with a little less than half of our testers absolutely loving them — as in never wanting to take them off — while the rest found them almost unbearably uncomfortable and unstable. This is a high-risk/ high-reward situation. If these buds happen to fit your ears well you'll likely love them, but based on our experience there's a good chance they just won't fit at all. So, make sure to order them from a retailer that offers returns. If you're seeking more waterproofing, the upgraded Jabra Elite Active 75t offers total IPX7 protection but suffers from the same polarizing fit issue as the non-active version. Additionally, the extra protection dampens the sound quality a bit. That said, if they fit, they'll be a hit.
Read review: Jabra Elite 75t
Why You Should Trust Us
We enlisted a team of runners to test the stability, sweat resistance, and long-term comfort of our running headphones. Leading this team is Laura Casner, a seasoned runner who has been consistently participating in ultra marathons for the past 12 years, the longest of which was 50 miles. Authors Michelle Powell and Max Mutter led the audio portions of our testing. The duo has been assessing the relative audio quality of consumer products for the past 5 years, having now tested and reviewed more than 150 headphones, earbuds, speakers, soundbars, and turntables.
To determine the running prowess of each of these headphones we had our team of runners use each pair multiple times in various conditions, racking up well over 100 miles in the process. After garnering opinions concerning comfort, stability, and general sound quality from these runners, we then brought the headphones into the lab for some rigorous, side-by-side sound quality testing. We used a multitude of musical genres and podcasts to determine each pair's relative bass, mid, and treble quality, overall clarity, and fullness. After all this was said and done we then fully charged each pair and ran them until they died in order to measure battery life.
Analysis and Test Results
We divided our analysis into three main categories: running performance, sound quality, and battery life. Within each of these metrics we conducted multiple tests to ensure that you can find a pair that will stay secure and comfy throughout your run while sounding good and lasting long enough to keep you motivated through the final mile.
The runners on our testing team used each pair of headphones on multiple runs that ranged from sweat fests in midday heat to chilly dawn adventures to long sessions on the treadmill. These masochists took careful note of which models were light and securely fit as to barely be noticeable while pounding the pavement, and which annoyingly tugged on their ears with each stride. They also paid careful attention to how perspiration affected each model's overall stability and comfort.
Our favorite model in this regard is the Jaybird Vista. The different earpieces offered by these earbuds allowed all of our testers to find a comfortable, stable fit, and the feathery weight all but eliminated any annoying tugging sensations in the ears. These buds are also IPX7 waterproof, so no worries if you happen to drop them in a puddle.
If you're one that appreciates extra stability in your headphones both the Beats by Dre Powerbeats Pro and the Powerbeats3 use over-ear hooks that create a rock-solid fit. However, those hooks can interfere with sunglasses, making them a poor choice for sunny locales.
Conversely, the Apple AirPods Pro lack any sort of ear fins, making them feel a bit less stable than some of the other models. However, most of our testers found the silicon earpieces to provide a secure enough purchase for running.
The Jabra Elite 75t has an odd design that tends to fit people's ears either perfectly or terribly. If you happen to fall into the former category, these buds will be great for running. If you fall in the latter category, however, we doubt you'll want to wear these buds for more than a few minutes.
We assessed sound quality in two ways — somewhat subjectively while listening to our favorite playlists while running, and more objectively in our testing lab by comparing clarity, separation, and fullness side-by-side. In this manner we were able to find the best sounding running headphones, no matter what you prefer to listen to while you run.
Though we found the fit a bit polarizing, the Jabra Elite 75t was unequivocally the best sounding pair of earbuds we tested. This sound quality is built off the bass power, which is impressively round yet well-controlled. That detail and control continues through the mid and treble ranges with great clarity and good separation.
Though the Jabra Elite 75t clearly set itself apart from the rest of the field when it comes to sound quality, there were a number of models that fell just slightly off the pace in our testing. For example, the Jaybird Vista offers great clarity and quality from the bass through the treble frequencies but lacks just a bit of the bass power of the Jabra Elite 75t. Both the Beats Powerbeats Pro and the Powerbeats3 offer a warmer and more bass-forward sound. This works perfectly for upbeat running tunes, but you lose some detail if you delve into acoustic compositions or podcasts. The AirPods Pro sound just a bit thinner than most models on this list, but engaging the noise cancelling technology can often lend the music more body, particularly when listening in noisy environments.
Having your playlist cut out before the end of your run can be a borderline devastating experience. Luckily, all of the buds we tested can easily last through an average run, but some are better suited to ultramarathoners or those that often forget to charge their electronics. We tested battery life by putting every fully-charged pair of headphones on 75% volume and looping the same 2-hour playlist until the batteries gave out. For truly wireless earbuds we considered the battery life of the buds themselves, not of the battery in the charging case.
The winner in this metric is the JBL Reflect Mini 2 that lasted an impressive 11.5 hours in our battery test. The Jabra Elite 75t and the Beats By Dre Powerbeats Pro followed closely behind, both lasting 11 hours. The Powerbeats3 also hit the double digit mark, posting a time of 10 hours. All of these models would be a good choice for ultramarathoners looking for exceptional battery life.
Following these over-achievers, battery life drops off somewhat precipitously with the 7.5 hour life of the Aftershokz Air being the closest competitor. The Jabra Elite 75t clocked in at 7 hours.
Even the worst performers in our battery life tests, which includes the Jaybird Vista (5.75 hours) and the Apple AirPods Pro (5 hours), are more than capable of lasting through the entirety of a marathon.
Logging miles can be infinitely more enjoyable with a good pair of running headphones, but a bad pair of running headphones can quickly become an unbearable annoyance and ruin your outing. We hope our testing results will help you find a pair that both falls into the former category and fits your needs and budget.
— Max Mutter and Michelle Powell