Excalibur 3926TB Review
Pros: Massive capacity, quick clean-up trays, uniform food results
Cons: Difficult to clean interior, no viewing window, expensive
Compare to Similar Products
$299.99 at Amazon
$127.49 at Amazon
$159.99 at Amazon
|$60 List||$60 List|
$46.39 at Amazon
|Pros||Massive capacity, quick clean-up trays, uniform food results||Metal trays, easy clean-up, digital interface||Accurate temperature controls, easy clean-up, nice looking||Easy to clean, economic, simplistic controls||Low-cost, minimalistic, quick and easy clean-up|
|Cons||Difficult to clean interior, no viewing window, expensive||Temperature settings in 10 minute increments, inaccurate on high heat settings||Food sticks to trays, poor dried meat outcomes||Poor temperature regulation, flimsy trays||Single setting controls, no timer|
|Bottom Line||This is our preferred option if you're after high-volume dehydration and professional results||A modern-looking machine with intuitive controls, metal trays, consistent heat, and primo outcomes||This high performance, middle capacity dehydrator is the best-looking machine of the lot||This affordable stackable dehydrator offers copious square footage that is easy to clean||A minimalistic, fixed temperature machine that requires monitoring, but is easy to clean|
|Rating Categories||Excalibur 3926TB||Magic Mill Food Deh...||Cosori Machine||Hamilton Beach 32100A||Nutrichef PKFD12|
|Temperature Accuracy (25%)|
|Ease Of Cleaning (25%)|
|Ease Of Use (25%)|
|Specs||Excalibur 3926TB||Magic Mill Food Deh...||Cosori Machine||Hamilton Beach 32100A||Nutrichef PKFD12|
|Outside Dimensions||19" x 17" x 12.5"||18" x 14" x 13"||13.4" x 17.8" x 12.4"||10.5" x 13" x 11"||12" x 7.5" x 13"|
|Capacity||15 sq ft||N/a||6 sq ft||3.75 sq ft||3.25 sq ft|
|Tray Dimensions||15" x 15"||13" x 12"||12" x 13"||10.5" x 13"||12" diameter|
|Number of Trays||9||7||6||5||5|
|Tray Material||Plastic||Stainless steel||Stainless steel||Plastic||Plastic|
|Temperature Range (F)||105-165||95-165||95-165||100-160||Max 180|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Quality and Consistency
The most important aspect of a dehydrator's performance is how the food coming out of it tastes and feels. While the dehydration process is simple enough to understand, it can be easy to mess up. The 3926TB produces uniformly delectable results in terms of texture, evenness, and flavor with beef jerky, vegetables, and fruit.
Easy to Use and Accurate
The main contributors to quality outcomes with a dehydrator are timing and consistent internal temperature. When a product is designed to allow these elements to be controlled by the user it can help a great deal. The 3926TD has a pair of knobs to manage time and temperature. The problem is that the temperature knob is marked off in temperature ranges, making precision temperature settings difficult to attain. This is a likely cause of the temperature deviations we observed in our test.
Our testing has revealed that, with few exceptions, dehydrators are a bit of a pain to clean up. There are two parts to this process. First, there are the trays. Next is the interior and in particular the floor of the machine where all the drippings accumulate. The Excalibur has easy to clean trays thanks to its removable, non-stick mesh tray liners. The interior of the machine is another story. The plastic of this model has a rough texture, and as such it adds some difficulty to the wipe-down process. However, we've seen much worse, and it's nothing a little elbow grease can't overcome.
The 3926TD is a very expensive dehydrator. However, this hefty price tag is congruent with the size and performance of the product. As such, we think this model is well worth the money assuming that you actually need the tray space.
The Excalibur delivers a consistent, high-quality performance in our side-by-side tests. That is not to say that there are no other machines that delivered similar results, but none that boast the capacity of this machine. It's a large, expensive production dehydrator that is designed for serious cooks. If you're looking to make dehydration a regular part of your life, this is the model for you.
— Nick Miley and Michelle Powell
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More