Reviews You Can Rely On

Singer 4423 Heavy Duty Review

A low-cost mechanical machine that is easy to use and set up
Singer 4423 Heavy Duty
Credit: Singer
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:   $280 List | $179.99 at Amazon
Pros:  Inexpensive, easy to use and set up
Cons:  Slightly below average sewing performance
Manufacturer:   Singer
By David Wise and Austin Palmer  ⋅  Oct 25, 2016
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
50
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#7 of 11
  • Sewing - 40% 4
  • Ease Of Use - 30% 6
  • Ease Of Set-Up - 20% 6
  • Buttonholes - 10% 4

Our Verdict

The Singer 4423 Heavy Duty is a basic mechanical sewing machines, that did an alright job in our tests. While this was far from our top performers, this no-frills machine could be a good entry-level machine with a price to match.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award Best Buy Award  Best Buy Award 
Price $280 List
$179.99 at Amazon
$240 List$210 List
$209.99 at Amazon
$240 List
$239.99 at Amazon
$100 List
Overall Score Sort Icon
50
69
62
58
46
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Inexpensive, easy to use and set upGreat value, excellent buttonholes, easy to useEconomical, easy to useEasy to use, solid buttonholesInexpensive, easy to set up
Cons Slightly below average sewing performanceStitches are slightly inferior to the top models, built-in light could be betterAverage sewing performanceLackluster stitching quality, priceyButtonholes could be better, stitch quality isn't amazing
Bottom Line A low-cost mechanical machine that is easy to use and set upThis user-friendly model is great for beginners and features above-average performance across the boardThis is a great inexpensive machine for those just starting out, though more advanced users might require a higher-performing modelThis bare-bones computerized sewing machine failed to wow us, even though it is very easy to useIf you're seeking a basic sewing machine on a super tight budget, the XM2701 is a decent option
Rating Categories Singer 4423 Heavy Duty Brother XR9550PRW Brother CS6000i Brother HC1850 Brother XM2701
Sewing (40%)
4.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
Ease Of Use (30%)
6.0
8.0
8.0
8.0
5.0
Ease Of Set Up (20%)
6.0
7.0
6.0
6.0
8.0
Buttonholes (10%)
4.0
7.0
6.0
6.0
3.0
Specs Singer 4423 Heavy Duty Brother XR9550PRW Brother CS6000i Brother HC1850 Brother XM2701
Sewing Speed 1,100 800 850 850 800
Built in Stitches 23 110 60 130 27
Buttonhole Styles 1 8 7 8 1
Buttonhole Sewing (how many steps) 1-Step 1-Step 1-Step 1-Step 1-Step
Maximum Stitch Width 6mm 7mm 7mm 7mm 5mm
Maximum Stitch Length 4mm 5mm 5mm 5mm 4mm
Thread Cutter Built-in Built-in Built-in Built-in Built-in
Automatic Bobbin Winder Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Twin Needle Capability Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Weight 14.5 lbs. 10.3 lbs. 9.4 lbs. 10.8 lbs. 12.7 lbs.

Our Analysis and Test Results

Marketed as Heavy Duty, this robust sewing machine advertises a metal interior frame, stainless steel bed plate, and a stronger motor. While being touted as heavy duty, the 4423 doesn't come close to the strength and power of an industrial machine, but it did make it through the heavier fabrics we tested with ease. This model earned an average score of 50 out of 100, but had the lowest price out of any models we tested.

Performance Comparison


A basic mechanical sewing machine with an industrial look.
A basic mechanical sewing machine with an industrial look.
Credit: Kat Elliott

Sewing


The 4423 received a 4 out of 10 in the most important metric — a somewhat paltry score. This category makes up 40% of the total score, with scores being determined by comparing the machine's long straight, zigzag, and scallop stitch, as well as their aptitude at attaching a zipper. The first stitch that we tested on this machine, the long straight stitch, was plagued by persistent tension issues across our range of test fabrics. It wavered from too loose, to so tight that the bobbin thread was pulled through.

The 4423's zigzag stitch was fine, with higher quality and consistency on the easier to sew fabrics, and dropped on the more difficult ones — like satin.

The 4423 struggled a little on satin, but still produced an...
The 4423 struggled a little on satin, but still produced an acceptable stitch. (#7)
Credit: Kat Elliott

It seemed to struggle a little with the scallop stitches, producing ones that were slightly subpar. It did an acceptable job at attaching the zipper, with no bunches or aberrant stitches around the end stop of the zipper, a problem other machines seemed to have.

Ease of Use


To assess the ease of use for each machine, we looked at how clear and easy to understand the directions printed on the machine are, the amount of light provided, type of thread cutter and the presence (or absence!) of features like automatic sewing or needle stop position adjustability. The 4423 performed above average, earning a 6 out of 10 in this metric.

Similar to its older cousin, the 4423 ease of use relies on its...
Similar to its older cousin, the 4423 ease of use relies on its simplicity.
Credit: Kat Elliott

Every feature on this machine is very clearly labeled, except the stitch selection. The stitch selection wheel has pairs of stitches, one in blue and one in red, with a separate knob that selects between the blue and the red stitches. While simple, this method is not immediately apparent, and briefly stymied us when we first went to use the machine.

The Singer 4423 has a grand total of 23 stitches.
The Singer 4423 has a grand total of 23 stitches.
Credit: Kat Elliott

This machine does not have any recommendations for which presser foot to use with each stitch, making it a little more intimidating for beginners. This machine does have a decent work light, enough where you could get away without supplemental lighting. The 4423 does lack automatic sewing, and consistent needle stopping position — something to be expected on such a basic mechanical sewing machine.

Ease of Setup


The 4423 is a basic machine, and is about average to set up, earning a slightly above average score of 6 out of 10. While the threading directions on this machine are similar to others, this machine has a much darker body, making the instructions higher contrast and easier to read. This is especially true of threading the bobbin cover, where it possible to actually see the directions compared to comparable machines.

The bobbin cover and directions are identical to the Singer 4452.
The bobbin cover and directions are identical to the Singer 4452.
Credit: Kat Elliott

The needle threader works well on this model, but it does require a decent amount of dexterity to operate, and occasionally may feel that it was designed for someone with an extra hand.

Button Work


The Singer 4423 struggles a little when it came to making buttonholes, lacking some of the nicer features that other computerized machines offered. This performance netted it a subpar 4 out of 10. This machine does not stop automatically when sewing a buttonhole, requiring a little more care and attention than some of the other machines to not ball up the thread at the end.

The Singer Heavy-Duty machines do not stop automatically upon...
The Singer Heavy-Duty machines do not stop automatically upon completion, resulting in errors like this if you aren't paying attention.
Credit: Kat Elliott

We also noticed that this buttonhole does not seem to lock as well as the other ones, and was more prone to unraveling and that it was substantially more difficult to line up the buttonhole in the correct spot.

Value


While this model is lower on the price axis, it is also low on the performance one. This fails to fulfill our criteria for making it a good value.

Conclusion


The Singer 4423 is an economical, basic mechanical sewing machine. While there were no terrible drawbacks on this product, you get what you pay for and the performance of this model fails to impress. We feel that there were other models that offered much better performance for only slightly more cost, and are worth saving up the extra penny.

David Wise and Austin Palmer