This headset is exceptionally comfortable to wear and is incredibly immersive. It's easy to use and while it doesn't offer quite the same level of interactiveness that the tethered headsets have, this product retails at a fraction of the price.
Samsung Gear VR Review
Pros: Comfortable, Immersive, very easy to set up
Cons: Not as interactive, limited compatibility
Compare to Similar Products
Samsung Gear VR
$113.58 at Amazon
Check Price at Amazon
$199 at Amazon
$264.00 at Amazon
$199.68 at Amazon
|Pros||Comfortable, Immersive, very easy to set up||Highly interactive, incredibly immersive, comfortable||Extremely easy to use, exceptionally user-friendly, very visually immersive||Exceptionally visually immersive, very user friendly, highly interactive||Highly interactive, incredibly easy to set-up|
|Cons||Not as interactive, limited compatibility||Expensive, difficult setup process||Experiences more limited than tethered headsets||Not super comfortable, only works with PlayStation||Pricey, limited library of games compared to other platforms|
|Bottom Line||The best of the best when it comes to mobile headsets, but only if you have one of the compatible Samsung phones||The Vive is the best of the best and the perfect pick for the VR enthusiast||The Go is an excellent, all-around headset that makes great VR experiences available to everyone||The PlayStation VR is a fantastic introduction to VR gaming, provided you already own a PS4||While the 6-DOF motion tracking is quite cool, the Mirage is hampered by its high price and limited number of experiences|
|Rating Categories||Samsung Gear VR||HTC Vive||Oculus Go||PlayStation VR||Lenovo Mirage Solo|
|Visual Immersiveness (20%)|
|User Friendliness (15%)|
|Ease Of Setup (10%)|
|Specs||Samsung Gear VR||HTC Vive||Oculus Go||PlayStation VR||Lenovo Mirage Solo|
|Phones that fit||Samsung Only||N/A||N/A, but smartphone required for initial setup||N/A||N/A|
|Adjustable Lenses||Only front to back, but the dial is pretty rigid making it easier to get the best focus||Only side to side||No||No, need to move the headset around||No|
|Sound||Phone||Headphone Jack or PC||Built-in, or headphone jack||Headphone Jack or TV||Headphones|
|Available Controllers / Remotes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Field of View||101||110||101||100||110|
|Refresh Rate||N/A||90Hz||60Hz or 72Hz||120Hz, 90Hz||75Hz|
|Room For Glasses?||Great, room for days||A little tight, but the Oculs Rift is tighter||Snug; there is a glasses spacer included. You can also opt for perscription lenses||- Fits fine with glasses, but lets in a lot more light||Yes. They can be a little snug with larger glasses|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Gear VR is an awesome mobile VR headset, with the only major drawback being the limited number of compatible phones. This product only works with a handful of the latest and greatest Samsung phones, so you are out of luck if you have anything else. However, this model is the clear choice if you are searching for a mobile VR platform and have one of the compatible smartphones.
To rank and score these products, we bought the top models available and tested them head-to-head to evaluate their performance. We grouped these tests into five weighted metrics, with our findings detailed below.
Comprising the largest portion of the overall score out of all of our rating metrics, Interactiveness takes credit for 35% of the final score. We compared the motion tracking accuracy of the headset and controllers and how you interacted with the device to determine the score for each product, with the Gear VR earning a slightly subpar 4 out of 10, comparing poorly with the other headsets.
While this score may be a little on the low side, it is the highest out of all the mobile headsets. The tethered models track your motion throughout the room, not just where you are looking, giving them a distinct edge over the mobile headsets in this set of test.
It is decently easy to interact with the headset, with a few buttons and a directional trackpad built right into the side of the headset.
There is also a handheld controller with a touchpad that can be used as an alternative interface method.
The Gear VR does a solid job at tracking where you are looking, though it does not track when you move throughout the room. The motion tracking of the remote is also decently accurate — on par with the Google Daydream — but it will occasionally drift, requiring you to reset the center position to the center of where you are facing by holding down a button on the controller.
Ranking next behind Interactiveness, our Visual Immersiveness group of tests merits 20% of the total score, based on our comparison of the visual quality, sharpness and resolution, and field of view, as well as how well each headset blocked out ambient light. The performance of the Gear VR underwent a marked increase from the previous metric, earning a score of 9 out of 10 — one of the best of the entire group.
The Gear VR does an excellent job of blocking out ambient light, by far the best of the bunch. This headset has a form-fitting mask that fits comfortably against your face, preventing any light leaks.
This headset has a decently wide field of view, claimed at 101° and only displaying slightly less of our test image than the Oculus. The resolution of the display depends on the phone used, but we found the image to be crisp and sharp, with overall excellent viewing quality when using a Samsung S8 as a test phone.
Comfort came next in terms of importance, accounting for 20% of the overall score. We evaluated how it felt to wear each headset for a long period of time, whether or not there is adequate room to wear glasses, and if there is enough ventilation to keep the optics from fogging. The Gear VR again scored very well, meriting another 9 out of 10 for this metric and putting it at the top of the pack.
The form-fitting soft gasket also makes the headset exceptionally comfortable, in addition to blocking out ambient light. The Gear VR is also exceptionally roomy, leaving plenty of room for glasses. However, it was only about average in terms of ventilation, which could cause your face to get sweaty if worn for long periods of time.
Accounting for 15% of the final score, our User Friendliness metric assessed how easy it is to hook up the audio system for each product, whether or not it was easy to inadvertently press buttons on your phone while using the headset, and how much work it took to get your phone ready for use in the headset. The Gear VR scored alright in this metric, earning a 6 out of 10 for its overall above average performance, comparing decently well with the other headsets.
It is quite easy to add sound to your experience when using the Gear VR, either by playing audio through your phone's speakers or by adding a set of headphones to improve it even more. The headphone port is easily accessible when using this headset, so it's no trouble at all to connect a pair.
It is a little more work to get the phone setup in the headset, as it actually plugs into the charging port at the bottom of the phone and has a pair of clamps that securely hold the phone in place. This also means that you usually have to take the phone out the case to place it in the headset, but it makes it almost impossible to accidentally hit any buttons on your phone.
Ease of Setup
Finally, our Ease of Setup metric takes credit for the residual 10% of the overall score. We compared how long it took to install the hardware and software, as well as what the hardware requirements are to run each system properly to determine the score, with the Gear VR doing a solid job, earning an 8 out of 10 for its performance. The following graphic shows how this stacked up against the rest of the group.
There is minimal hardware setup to get this headset ready to go, only taking a few minutes to attach the straps to the headset and remote, install the batteries in the remote, and adjust and focus the lenses to your own particular interpupillary distance.
We had to install a few apps on the phone to get the software side of things ready to go, taking a bit longer than the other mobile headsets. However, we encountered no difficulties, it just took slightly longer. This model did lose a few points by having a limited set of phones that are compatible, fewer than some of its competitors.
The Gear VR is a little on the pricey side for a mobile headset, but does deliver a premium VR experience.
If you want a top product when it comes to mobile VR media or gaming experiences and have a Samsung smartphone, then look no further than the Gear VR. It's comfortable and visually immersive, offering an awesome experience at a fraction of the price of a tethered system.
— David Wise and Austin Palmer