Reviews You Can Rely On

Oreck Commercial XL Review

Feeling a little let down by the infomercials, this vacuum didn't do very well in our tests at all
Oreck Commercial XL
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:   $200 List | $167.96 at Amazon
Pros:  Good at cleaning up pet hair, lightweight
Cons:  Mediocre at cleaning hard floors and carpet
Manufacturer:   Oreck
By David Wise and Austin Palmer  ⋅  Jul 12, 2017
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
53
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#9 of 10
  • Carpet Cleaning - 35% 4
  • Ease of Use - 25% 6
  • Handling - 20% 6
  • Hard Surface Cleaning - 10% 4
  • Pet Hair - 10% 8

Our Verdict

This run-of-the-mill, upright vacuum of infomercial fame performed quite poorly in our tests, finishing towards the bottom of the pack. On top of that, we feel that the Oreck Commercial XL is disproportionately priced for its performance, with a comparable list price to much more accomplished vacuums. For the price, you can find a better-performing model that doesn't require the use of a bag to collect your debris.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Oreck Commercial XL
Awards  Best Buy Award  Best Buy Award  
Price $200 List
$167.96 at Amazon
$200 List
$199.99 at Amazon
$180 List$88 List
$79.99 at Amazon
$73 List
Overall Score Sort Icon
53
71
63
58
50
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Good at cleaning up pet hair, lightweightGood price, cleans carpet very well, picks up pet hair with easeExcellent at cleaning up pet hair, solid cleaning performance across the boardInexpensive, great for pet hair, solid carpet cleaningInexpensive, maneuverable, solid at picking up pet hair
Cons Mediocre at cleaning hard floors and carpetNot particularly impressive at cleaning hard floorsShorter reachLackluster at cleaning hard floors, so-so ease of useDoesn't clean hard floors or carpet very well
Bottom Line Feeling a little let down by the infomercials, this vacuum didn't do very well in our tests at allIf you are searching for a new vacuum on a budget, then this is a great betThis vacuum is a great value, performing well across the board and retailing at a great priceIf you are shopping on a particularly tight budget for a new vacuum, this is a good optionThis cheap vacuum isn't terrible, but there are far better options for the same price
Rating Categories Oreck Commercial XL Navigator Lift-Away... Shark Navigator Deluxe Eureka PowerSpeed BLACK+DECKER AirSwi...
Carpet Cleaning (35%)
4.0
7.0
6.0
6.0
3.0
Ease Of Use (25%)
6.0
7.0
6.0
5.0
5.0
Handling (20%)
6.0
7.0
6.0
6.0
8.0
Hard Surface Cleaning (10%)
4.0
6.0
6.0
3.0
3.0
Pet Hair (10%)
8.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
8.0
Specs Oreck Commercial XL Navigator Lift-Away... Shark Navigator Deluxe Eureka PowerSpeed BLACK+DECKER AirSwi...
Vacuum type Upright Upright Upright Upright Upright
Model Number XL2100RHS NV356E NV42 NEU182A BDASL202
Bag Type Bag Bagless Bagless Bagless Bagless
Cleaning Path Width 12" 11.25" 11.25" 13.25" 12"
Measured Brush Width 9.5" 9" 9" 10.5" 11"
Measured Weight 10.5 lbs 14.4 lbs 15.9 lbs 10.1 lbs 9.4 lbs
Variable Suction Control No Yes Yes No No
Brush On/Off Switch No Yes Slow No No
Measured Maximum Reach 37' 31' 27' 25' 20.8'
Measured Power Cord Length 35' 30' 25' 24' 20'
Automatic Cord Rewind No No No No No
Measured Noise 79.5 dBa 73 dBa 74 dBa 76 dBa 75.4 dBa
Swivel Head No Yes No No Yes
Carry Handle No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Soft Bumper Yes No No No No

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Oreck XL scored below average in both of our floor cleaning metrics, only really doing well at collecting pet hair. This model lacks many of the features and functions of other models and is about as bare-bones as you can get.

Performance Comparison


The Oreck XL costs more than we think it's worth based on performance.
The Oreck XL costs more than we think it's worth based on performance.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman

Carpet Cleaning


For this metric, worth 35% of the total score, we used rice, oats, cereal, and flour to compare and assess the performance of each vacuum cleaner, testing each model on both low-pile and medium-pile carpet. The Oreck delivered an unimpressive performance.

The Oreck was a bit of a disappointment in this metric.
The Oreck was a bit of a disappointment in this metric.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman

The Oreck did a terrible job at collecting rice on shallow carpet, taking over six passes, and still leaving a ton of residual debris behind. This model tended to suck in the rice, crush it up, then leave it on the carpet, rather than actually collecting it. It did even worse on the fluffy carpet, taking over 10 passes to do a barely passable job. The Oreck did even worse at collecting flour, performing poorly on flat carpet and receiving one of the lowest scores of all our tested models. It didn't improve on fluffy carpet, doing the worst job of the entire group.

The Oreck did not impress at collecting flour.
The Oreck did not impress at collecting flour.
Credit: Austin Palmer

For the cereal test, the Oreck also delivered a subpar performance. It did poorly on the first pass, once again crushing up the debris and spitting it out, rather than collecting it. It did about the same on the fluffy carpet, still leaving some residual debris after 14 passes. For the oatmeal test, more of the same subpar results. It took over five passes on both flat and fluffy carpet to get somewhat clean, with plenty of debris left over.

The Oreck wasn't great at collecting Cheerios.
The Oreck wasn't great at collecting Cheerios.
Credit: Austin Palmer

Ease of Use


This metric takes credit for 25% of the total score. The Oreck XL did an alright job in this set of tests, scoring just barely above average. We compared how easy it was for each model to transition between hard and soft floors, clean in close to edges and under a sofa, the maximum reach, and noise level.

This vacuum is a little easier to use than some of the others.
This vacuum is a little easier to use than some of the others.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman

The Oreck XL doesn't have any option to adjust for a hard floor, low-pile, or medium-pile carpet, so it lost some points. This model did alright at cleaning in close to edges but faltered in tight corners. It also didn't do the best at getting debris right in front of it.

The Oreck also did exceptionally well in our edging test.
The Oreck also did exceptionally well in our edging test.
Credit: Austin Palmer

When cleaning under our simulated sofa, the Oreck did quite well, reaching 11"-12" in our test. This model also has a decently long reach, comparing favorably to others in our lineup at 37 feet. However, it's unfortunately on the loud side, measuring in at 79.5 dBa on our meter.

The Oreck working on the mess under our test "sofa".
The Oreck working on the mess under our test "sofa".
Credit: Austin Palmer

Handling


When it came to maneuvering, this model was quite mediocre. It's light enough to easily push or pull with minimal effort but doesn't swivel like the higher-end models. And, despite a decently light weight, this vacuum doesn't have an accessory hose, making it exceptionally difficult to clean a flight of stairs.

There wasn't really a good way to clean stairs with the Oreck.
There wasn't really a good way to clean stairs with the Oreck.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman

Hard Surface Cleaning


The Oreck XL delivered a somewhat disappointing performance here as well. We again tested with flour, oats, cereal, and rice, but this time used a section of laminate wood flooring as the test surface.

The Oreck did alright collecting rice, getting the vast majority of it with only two passes. However, it flung a little bit of rice too, creating an additional mess. The flour test went a bit better, with it collecting all of the debris on the surface, as well as some of the flour deep in the cracks, as long as it was running parallel to the crack.

Unless we ran the Oreck parallel to the cracks in our wood floor, it...
Unless we ran the Oreck parallel to the cracks in our wood floor, it would leave some behind.
Credit: Austin Palmer

This vacuum failed our Cheerio collection challenge, only pushing them around and piling the cereal up, rather than actually collecting it. This model also fared poorly with oats, creating a small disaster by flinging the oats around haphazardly. We felt we would have been better served by a broom.

Trying to pick up oats with the Oreck made us long for a nice broom...
Trying to pick up oats with the Oreck made us long for a nice broom instead.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman

Pet Hair


For our final testing metric, we compared the proficiency of each vacuum at collecting pet hair, donated from a local pet groomer. This metric consisted of a single task: collect 5 grams of hair pressed into a section of medium-pile carpet. The Oreck actually did quite well, collecting 89% of the hair laid out. This wasn't too far behind the top-scoring model which collected 96% of the total hair.

Value


This model isn't a great value, as it's an oddly pricey vacuum that delivers a lackluster performance.

Conclusion


This bare-bones model didn't really excel in our tests and costs the same or more than models that perform significantly better. This makes it hard to recommend the Oreck Commercial XL.

David Wise and Austin Palmer