The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of tech gear

YUNEEC Mantis Q Review

An inexpensive model that doesn't live up to its specs and fails to be a good budget option
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:   $500 List
Pros:  Relatively small and lightweight
Cons:  Very shaky video, less than responsive controls
Manufacturer:   YUNEEC
By Max Mutter and Steven Tata  ⋅  Jan 29, 2019
  • Share this article:
49
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#12 of 14
  • Video Quality - 40% 3
  • Flight Performance - 25% 7
  • Portability - 20% 6
  • Ease of Use - 15% 5

Our Verdict

We've seen a slew of small, portable models hit the market trying to compete with similar offerings from DJI. The YUNEEC Mantis Q falls into that category and unfortunately also falls short of being a viable DJI competitor. The Mantis Q's relatively shaky and low-quality video, along with a less than comfortable controller, make this a poor choice for most people. For significantly less you can now get a far superior DJI Spark and its corresponding controller. The only metric where the Mantis Qis better than the DJI Spark is in maximum flight time, offering an impressive 33 minutes to the Spark's 16. However, the Spark's video and flight performance attributes are so much better that you'll get twice the video quality, if only half the flight time.


Compare to Similar Products

 
This Product
YUNEEC Mantis Q
Awards  Editors' Choice Award   Editors' Choice Award 
Price $500 List$1,729 List$1,439 List$1,800 List$800 List
$709.99 at Amazon
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Relatively small and lightweightExcellent video quality, Great flight performance, relatively portbaleGood video quality, optical zoom, portableTop quality, stable video, great flight performance, built in controller screenGreat video quality, portable, easy to use, many intelligent flight modes
Cons Very shaky video, less than responsive controlsExpensiveExpensiveExpensiveExpensive, relatively short battery life
Bottom Line An inexpensive model that doesn't live up to its specs and fails to be a good budget optionAn impressive combination of video quality and portabilityOptical zoom adds interesting creative possibilities to an already great productPerfect for those looking for professional quality video and that appreciate the convenience of not needing to connect a smartphoneBest balance of video quality and portability on the market
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
49
100
0
93
100
0
85
100
0
85
100
0
84
Rating Categories YUNEEC Mantis Q DJI Mavic 2 Pro DJI Mavic 2 Zoom DJI Phantom 4 Pro+ DJI Mavic Air
Video Quality (40%)
10
0
3
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
10
10
0
8
Flight Performance (25%)
10
0
7
10
0
10
10
0
10
10
0
10
10
0
8
Portability (20%)
10
0
6
10
0
7
10
0
7
10
0
3
10
0
9
Ease Of Use (15%)
10
0
5
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
Specs YUNEEC Mantis Q DJI Mavic 2 Pro DJI Mavic 2 Zoom DJI Phantom 4 Pro+ DJI Mavic Air
Video Resolutions 4K, 2.7K, 1080p, 720p 4K, 2.7K, 1080p, 720p 4K, 2.7K, 1080p, 720p 4K, 2.7K, 1080p, 720p 4K, 2.7K, 1080p, 720p
Weight 1.06 lb 2 lb 2 lb 3.1 lb 0.95 lb
Maximum Speed 44 mph 45 mph 45 mph 45 mph 43 mph
Maximum Claimed Flight Time 33 minutes 31 minutes 31 minutes 30 minutes 21 minutes
Diagonal Size (no props) 9 in 13.2 in 13.2 in 13.8 in 8.4 in
Video Format MP4, MOV MP4, MOV MP4, MOV MP4, MOV MP4, MOV

Our Analysis and Test Results

Lacking any sort of physical camera stabilization, the YUNEC Mantis Q just can't match the video captured by many other drones in its same price range.


Performance Comparison


The only thing we really like about the YUNEEC Mantis Q is its extended battery life and takeoff/landing stability. This rescued it from the bottom of our scoresheet, but not by much.

Video Quality


This is where the Matins Q lost favor with us, earning one of the lowest scores in the metric.


Not Really 4K


YUNEEC has been pushing the 4K camera of the Mantis Q as a selling point, but the reality is you'll probably never use that full 4K resolution. Why? Because the Mantis Q lacks a gimbal, opting instead for digital image stabilization. Shooting in full 4K resolution means the camera has absolutely no stabilization, resulting in dizzying footage if you do anything other than fly slowly in a straight line.

Dropping the resolution down to 1080p (the same as the rival DJI Spark) the Mantis Q adds some digital stabilization to the image. This is a vast improvement over the unstabilized 4K footage, but is still much shaker than footage filmed with the DJI Spark and its physically stabilized gimbal.


The Mantis Q's video is quite unstable.

Medicore Colors and Clarity


Apart from a lack of stabilization, the Mantis Q's video has an overall dull quality to it. Most colors look muted, lacking the pop you can see in video from the DJI Spark. The clarity also leaves a bit to be desired, as fast moving shots often slip into varying degrees of blurriness. These problems become even more exasperated in lowlight conditions, as the very small camera sensor struggles to soak up enough photons. Bottom line, the video isn't terrible, but chances are the smartphone in your pocket can produce substantially better footage.


The Mantis Q's video lack some color vibrancy, especially in low-light situations.

Flight Performance


If your main goal is to capture good aerial footage, the corresponding flight skills of the Mantis Q are somewhat lacking. If you mostly just want to zip around really fast and don't care too much about the resulting video, the Mantis Q's sport mode is actually quite good. These attributes combined earned the Mantis Q a slightly above average, but not exceptional flight performance score.


True to its beginner-friendly pedigree, the Mantis Q is very stable during both takeoff and landing. Once in the air, however, that stability gets a bit dicier. When we left it in a hover it would often drift up to 2 feet in altitude and to either side. That figure shrinks to about 6 inches for the competing DJI Spark.

The Mantis Q is super fun to buzz around in sport mode.
The Mantis Q is super fun to buzz around in sport mode.

Like the Spark, the Mantis Q is able to take off from your hand. You can even tell the Mantis Q to takeoff (more on that below). However, it lacks the Spark's ability to recognize and automatically land on your hand.

Autonomous Flight Features


The Mantis Q has the standard bevy of autonomous flight features, like orbit (pan 360˚ around a subject) and follow (automatically follow a subject), along with other automatic panning and zooming features. The one noticeable absence is any sort of cable cam feature, which would allow the drone to automatically fly in a set path while the pilot moves the camera around.

All of these features work and are relatively easy to use, but the lack of camera stability makes the resulting video look fairly poor. For example, when we used the follow feature we had trouble telling if the drone was struggling to follow the subject, or if the inherent camera instability just made it look that way. The DJI Spark was able to pull off all of these maneuvers with more panache in our testing.

The Mantis Q's autonomous flight features work quite well  but the video they capture is fairly low quality.
The Mantis Q's autonomous flight features work quite well, but the video they capture is fairly low quality.

Long Battery Life


The Mantis Q boasts an impressively long battery life of 33 minutes. While this may be a bit of an exaggeration, in our testing we were regularly able to fly 25+ minutes before needing to land. This is far better than the DJI Spark's 16 minutes, making it one of the few areas where the Mantis Q is superior to the Spark.

Sport Mode


This is another area where we do prefer the Mantis Q to the Spark. Sport mode allows the Mantis Q to fly up to 44 miles per hour (much faster than the Spark's 31mph), and it does turn and maneuver with a fair amount of agility. Also, flipping into sport mode and accepting the fact you're flying just for the fun of flying, not to capture any sort of video, makes many of the Mantis Q's limitations melt away. However, if you're just looking for a fast drone that is fun to fly around, there are less expensive options available.

Portability


With foldable arms and a fairly low weight of 1.06 pounds, the Mantis Q is quite portable. However, it still doesn't measure up to most of the other foldable models that have recently hit the market.


When looking at foldable drones, the models most comparable to the Mantis Q would be the DJI Mavic Air and the Parrot Anafi. These devices weigh 0.95 and 0.7 pounds, respectively. This makes them both appreciably lighter than the Mantis Q. Both of these models also come with carrying cases and have controllers that fold up, two portability features the Mantis Q lacks. Granted the Mavic Air and Anafi both cost more than the Mantis Q ($800 and $700), but both are also much more capable devices overall.

The Mantis Q is quite small and folds up into a packable shape  but lacks an included carrying case.
The Mantis Q is quite small and folds up into a packable shape, but lacks an included carrying case.

While the DJI Spark does not fold down, it actually weighs less than the Mantis Q (0.66 pounds), has a smaller overall form factor, and comes with a rigid foam carrying case, making it again a better choice than the Mantis Q in this arena.

Ease of Use


While the Mantis Q is quite easy to setup and operate, we found many aspects of its user experience to be a bit frustrating, resulting in a mediocre score.


Out of the box, the Mantis Q is simple to get up and flying. The drone intuitively unfolds and the props are easy to install. The YuneecPilot App quickly and easily pairs to the drone. You have the option of using only your phone as a controller, or docking your phone onto the included physical controller. We don't like phone-based controls in general due to their lack of tactile response, so we would highly recommend using the physical controller instead.

The controller isn't particularly comfortable to hold.
The controller isn't particularly comfortable to hold.

Outside of strict setup and operation, we aren't huge fans of the Mantis Q's user experience. The controller itself feels a bit chunky in hand without any ergonomic touches. In comparison, we felt much more comfortable using the controllers of the DJI Spark and the Parrot Anafi.

We also found the video downlink of the Mantis Q to be lacking. The live video feed from the camera often gets pixelated and can often be choppy. Again, for fun flying antics this is acceptable, but it makes framing a cinematic shot quite difficult. Both the DJI Spark and the Parrot Anafi have much crisper and more reliable video downlinks.

Voice Controls


The Mantis Q offers a unique voice control feature, which lets you say things like, takeoff, land, or take a picture, and the drone will respond accordingly. We found these commands to work quite reliably, but they felt a bit more gimmicky than useful. The only option we could see ourselves actually using would be the, "Take a photo," command, which is nice for aerial selfies. However, the DJI Spark lets you do the same thing with a hand gesture, so the Mantis Q doesn't gain much of a leg up in this respect.

Value


For $500, the YUNEEC Mantis Q offers poor video quality but decent flight performance. If you're looking for an inexpensive model for aerial videography, the $400 DJI Spark is a much better option. If you're just looking for a fun flying experience and don't care much about video quality, you'll likely be able to find a cheaper, more fun option in the world of racing drones.

Conclusion


The YUNEEC Mantis Q provides a fun flying experience but very poor video quality. We wouldn't recommend it to anyone looking to capture good footage, and it feels quite overpriced for non-video oriented flying fun.


Max Mutter and Steven Tata