Alera ALEEL42BME10B Elusion Series Review
Pros: Acceptably comfortable
Cons: Mediocre adjustability, harder to build
Compare to Similar Products
Alera ALEEL42BME10B Elusion Series
$143.98 at Amazon
$1,036 at Amazon
|$600 List||$1,595 List||$817 List|
$788.40 at Amazon
|Pros||Acceptably comfortable||Extremely comfortable, tons of adjustability, sturdy construction||Super easy to assemble, very adjustable||Appears quite durable, very adjustable||Appears well-built, comfortable|
|Cons||Mediocre adjustability, harder to build||Pricey||Could be a lot more comfortable, design isn’t universal||Exceptionally expensive, harder to assemble||Could have more adjustable features, pricey|
|Bottom Line||The Alera struggled to distinguish itself from the pack with its overall lackluster showing||Our favorite office chair that we have tested to date, the Leap is by far the best you can get||This chair definitely makes a style statement but we wish it were a bit more comfortable||It’s hard to justify spending an exorbitant amount for a chair that isn’t the absolute best||While the Think overall did well in our review, it didn’t quite make it onto our list of favorites|
|Rating Categories||ALEEL42BME10B...||Steelcase Leap||Herman Miller Sayl||Herman Miller Embody||Steelcase Think|
|Ease Of Assembly (5%)|
|Specs||ALEEL42BME10B...||Steelcase Leap||Herman Miller Sayl||Herman Miller Embody||Steelcase Think|
|Seat pan adjustment||No||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Adjustable lumbar support||Yes; The backrest moves up and down||Yes||Option available||Yes; You can adjust the amount, but not the location||Yes|
|Lumbar support||Yes; A slight protrusion||Yes||Option available||Yes||Yes|
|Tilt limiter||Yes; Only locks in the upright position||Yes; 5 stop points||Yes; 3 stop points||Yes; 4 stop points||Yes; 4 stop points|
|Armrest width adjustment||Yes; A knob underneath the chair that moves about an inch||Option available||Option available as a third-party upgrade||Yes||Option available|
|Swivel armrests||No||Option available||Option available as a third-party upgrade||No||Option available|
|Armrest depth adjustment||No||Option available||Option available as a third-party upgrade||No||Option available|
Our Analysis and Test Results
This office chair finished in the lower portion of the group, right behind the Modway Ergonomic Mesh and ahead of the SPACE Seating 5700E. It's more comfortable and has more adjustability than the SPACE and about the same as the level of comfort as the Modway. However, the Modway is easier to build and has quite a bit more adjustability. The Alera is also the most expensive of this trio.
In our quest to figure out which office chair is truly the best of them all, we looked at close to 50 different chairs, then picked out which ones displayed the most promise and bought them all to compare head-to-head. We scored each chair on how comfortable it is, how durable it appeared to be, the ease of assembly, and the level of adjustability, with the Alera's results highlighted below.
The first — and most important — round of tests was our series of comfort evaluations, which is responsible for half of the Alera's overall score. We had a panel of different testers try out each chair for a while, then rate how comfortable the various aspects of each one are and figure out how long they could sit in it without undue discomfort. The Alera did slightly above average, meriting a 6 out of 10.
A handful of our panel felt they could easily sit in this chair for 8-10 hours a day without any cause for complaint, but there were a few testers that felt they would only want to sit in this chair for 4-6 hours a day at the maximum.
When it came to judging the different parts of the chair, the seat cushion was almost universally rated on the more comfortable side, with only a single judge scoring it more on the mediocre side.
The response to the backrest was a bit more split, with half the testers rating it highly and the other half scoring it average or below. The Alera's favor fell even more when it came to its armrests, with a majority of our testers giving them uninspiring scores with regards to comfort.
Next, we compared how adjustable the backrest, seat, armrests, and reclining mechanism of each chair is. Additionally, we also rated each chair on how easy it is to configure it so you are seated in a proper ergonomic position. Altogether, these tests are responsible for just a bit over a third of the Alera's overall score. It did alright in this metric, meriting a 5 out of 10 for its middle-of-the-road results.
The backrest on this chair is reasonably high and can be moved up and down to adjust the location of the lumbar support. However, we weren't terribly impressed with it, as the small protrusion that was purportedly for lumbar support didn't seem to do all that much for many of our testers.
The armrests have about half the adjustability of the top models, only allowing you to move them in or out and set the height, not change the depth or angle.
You can't do much to the seat beside set its height and the reclining tension knob doesn't have the largest response, with even the lowest setting being on the stiffer side. We did like that the Alera has tilt limiter to lock you upright. It's also fairly easy to get this chair set up pursuant to proper ergonomic seating guidelines.
Responsible for 10% of the final score for the Alera, our durability metric assessed how well constructed each office chair is. We based the score on our own experience with the chair's wear and tear during our testing process and by researching other user reviews of this chair and looking for commonly encountered problems or component failures. Additionally, we also awarded points based on the length of the warranty period of each chair. The Alera earned a 6 out of 10 for its slightly above average constructions and durability.
In our opinion, we felt that the backrest on this chair already started to stretch out after a few months of testing, so we could see it completely wearing out quite quickly. We found a handful of other user experiences online that backed this up, noting that the backrest on their chair had completely stretched out so that your back was resting against the plastic frame. We also found a group of user reviews complaining that the chair began to squeak after a while or that they broke off one of the adjustment levers.
The warranty on this chair is alright, covering a 5-year term, but it is limited in scope.
Ease of Assembly
For the final 5% of the score for the Alera, we looked at the amount of effort it was to get this chair unpacked from its shipping carton and assembled. We also took into account the quality and helpfulness of the supplied instructions and other documentation. The Alera Elusion Series earned a 5 out of 10 for its somewhat involved process when it came to building it.
This chair took us 35-45 minutes to assemble, as you do have to build most of it before you can sit down. The instructions aren't especially great and the photos could be a lot better, but you still can follow them without too much difficulty.
This chair isn't a great value, with less expensive options significantly outperforming it.
The Alera screamed mediocrity in almost all of our tests and there are other chairs that we preferred much more in the same or lower price range, making us reticent to recommend it.
— David Wise and Austin Palmer