The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of tech gear

The Best Waffle Makers of 2019

Thursday October 3, 2019
  • Share this article:

In the interest of better breakfasts, we've researched dozens of the most compelling waffle makers of 2019 and bought and tested 8 of the best side-by-side. The good news? Most of these batter bakers cost about the same as a few trips to a fancy cafe. The bad news? They all look the same and it can be incredibly difficult to separate the duds from the rock stars. Luckily we've done the research for you, so you can avoid a bad breakfast. All of the waffle makers we list here are both popular and receive overwhelming positive user feedback, so you can buy without fear.


1

Best Overall Waffle Maker


Breville No-Mess


Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$129.95
at Amazon
See It

Size: 6.5 inch diameter | Style: Classic
Excellent taste
Less mess than competitors
7 shade settings
LED and audible indicators
Relatively expensive
Larger storage footprint

In our testing the Breville No-Mess made some near perfectly cooked, delicious, classic waffles that we've ever tasted. Two things really set the No-Mess apart from the competition. The first is its wraparound, non-stick moat, which catches any spilled batter and turns it into a crispy amuse bouche instead off a mess that needs to be cleaned up. The second is its very accurate and consistent shade settings. With 7 different settings, this machine can do amber and fluffy all the way to dark and crispy, and pretty much anything in between. And thanks to Breville's signature precision, you can be confident that each setting is going to yield the same results each and every time. Finally, both lights and beeps let you know when the iron is up to temperature, and when the waffle is done, eliminating any guesswork.

The major drawback to this machine is its price, as it is one of the most expensive single-waffle makers on the market. It is also one of the larger ones, taking up more counter space than most of the other makers of a similar cooking capacity. However, this extra cost and bulk certainly does translate into better performance and quality construction, so if you're willing to make an investment into having top-notch waffles at home for years to come, this is best option around.

Read review: Breville No-Mess

2

Fantastic Performance with Retro Styling


All-Clad Stainless Steel Classic


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$129.95
at Amazon
See It

Size: 6.5 inch diameter | Style: Classic
Excellent taste
7 shade settings
Classic aesthetics
LED and audible indicators
Relatively expensive
Quite bulky and heavy
Some surfaces can get hot

If you'd like to make homemade waffles a staple in your home, there's a good chance your waffle maker is going to become a permanent presence on the counter. In that case you may appreciate the all stainless steel, rugged look of the All-Clad Stainless Steel Classic. This heavy duty, built-to-last machine can churn out delicious waffles in 7 different shades from fluffy to crispy. It also has all of the pre-heating and fully-cooked indicators that one would expect from a top-notch appliance.

The biggest downside of the All-Clad is its relatively high price. Even if you are willing to spend extra on a more reliable and well-built machine, however, the All-Clad still has some weak points in relation to the comparatively priced Breville No-Mess. First off, the Breville's design essentially eliminates overflowing batter spills, whereas the All-Clad simply minizes them. Some surfaces of the All-Clad can also get quite hot to the touch, something we didn't experience with the Breville. Still, if the All-Clad is perfect with your kitchen decor, we don't think this machine is going to disappoint.

Read review: All-Clad Stainless Steel Classic

3

Belgian Style, Twice the Speed


Cuisinart Double Belgian


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$69.99
(30% off)
at Amazon
See It

Size: 7 inch diameter | Style: Belgian
Makes 2 waffles at once
Good taste/texture
Indicators lights and beeps
Very large and heavy
Can be difficult to clean

Most larger capacity waffle makers utilize a wide bed that can make for uneven batter distribution. The Cuisinart Double Belgian gets around that by stacking two round, flippable irons on top of one another, allowing for 2 delicious Belgian style to be made at once. Plus, helpful light and beeps let you know when the irons are ready to go, and when the waffles are done.

The one thing we really feel is lacking in the Cuisinart Double Belgian are removable griddles. Because this machine is so much larger and heavier than most (a whopping 13 pounds), trying to clean the girdles after use can be a bit of a hassle. Luckily the non-stick is usually pretty effective, so you shouldn't be stuck scrubbing too often. As long as you have storage space for this bulky device, it's the best way we've found for quickly making fluffy, belgian waffles quickly.

Read review: Cuisinart Double Belgian

4

Best Bang for the Buck


Presto FlipSide


Best Buy Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$39.99
(20% off)
at Amazon
See It

Size: 7 inch diameter | Style: Belgian
Great taste
Ability to flip
Small storage footprint
Takes up a lot of space when in use
Some condensation issues

Somehow early mornings in the office got a little easier when we had the Presto FlipSide around. In our testing it served up fluffy, evenly cooked waffles that sopped up syrup like a sponge. The unique hinged design means you get all the benefits of a waffle maker that actually flips over, without all of the unwieldy storage issues. In fact, it can lock in the upright position so you can easily slide into a cupboard. Nice touches like an indicator light that lets you know when the machine is up to temperature and a timer that lets you know when the waffle is done add a degree of user-friendliness. Finally, we found that the non-stick surface worked quite well and didn't leave any caked-on messes that required extra cleanup.

On the flip side (sorry, we couldn't resist) this waffle maker does have a couple of downsides. While the unit packs up nice and small for storage, the design does require quite a bit of counter real estate when in use. Also, while overall we'd call its waffles evenly cooked, one side does come out a bit crispier than the other. These, however, are very minor gripes, and we don't think they should dissuade you from upping your breakfast game.

Read review: Presto FlipSide

5

Great Waffles at a Low Price


Cuisinart WMR-CA Round Classic


Best Buy Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$19.99
(33% off)
at Amazon
See It

Size: 6.5 inch diameter | Style: Classic
Good taste and texture
Accurate browning settings
Simple controls
Construction feels flimsy
Many user reviews complain of durability issues

If you're looking to make waffles at home on the cheap, it's hard to beat the Cuisinart WMR-CA Round Classic. In our testing this machine was able to produce waffles with a similar level of taste and texture of the higher priced models, but for a fraction of the cost. We were especially impressed that every time we used one of the Round Classic's 5 different shade settings it reliably produced the same level of crispiness. Again, this kind of consistency is something we've generally found to carry a much larger price tag.

Unfortunately, the Cuisinart Round Classic's low price tag does come with some sacrifices, mainly in the realms of durability and user-friendliness. We found this machine's construction to be a bit on the shoddy side. For example, the unit itself feels poorly balanced and like it could tip over if given a chance, and the control has dial lots of extra play, requiring the wiggle it a bit to get it to the desired setting. It also lacks any sort of indicators, so you'll have to do some trial and error to get a feel for how long it takes to heat up and how long it takes to cook a waffle. If you're looking to make waffles an every weekend tradition, it's likely worth paying extra for a model that doesn't have these drawbacks. However, if you'll probably going to make waffles for a few special occasions a year, the Cuisinart Round Classic is an inexpensive and effective way to have that option at the ready.

Read review: Cuisinart WMR-CA Round Classic

6

Good Waffles on a Shoestring Budget


Oster CKSTWF2000


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$17.88
(11% off)
at Amazon
See It

Size: 8 inch diameter | Style: Belgian(ish)
Very inexpensive
Can adjust temperature (and thus crispiness)
Waffles on the thin side
Drips lots of condensation

If you're looking to spice up your breakfast spread but want to spend as little as possible, the Oster CKSTWF2000 is your best bet. In our testing it was able to make some great waffles with a nice crunch and a bit of fluff. The temperature control knob lets you find your desired point on the fluffy to crunchy spectrum, and a helpful ready light lets you know when everything is up to temperature.

Like all budget products, you do have to make some sacrifices with the CKSTWF2000. It is pretty easy to overload the unit with batter (we would suggest starting below the manufacturer's recommendation). Even if you get the batter right, there tends to be a good bit of condensation that drips off the front of the machine, requiring some wiping. The waffles also fall just a bit short of the fluffiness most people would require to truly call them Belgian. They're certainly leaps and bounds better than frozen waffles, but you might be disappointed if you're expecting a super fluffy restaurant style waffle.

Read review: Oster CKSTWF2000

7

Fluffy Waffles for Large Families


KRUPS GQ502D


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$57.90
(4% off)
at Amazon
See It

Size: 4.5 inch square | Style: Belgian
Large Capacity
Dishwasher safe, removable griddles
Can take long to heat up/cook
Corners more cooked than centers

If you don't want to feel like an assembly line worker while making Sunday breakfast for a large family, the KRUPS GQ502D is one of your best bets. This machine can churn out four fluffy waffles in one go, so nobody has to let their food get cold waiting for everyone to be served. Indicator lights and beeps let you know when the griddle is up to temperature and when the waffles are done. A shade knob also lets you adjust from a nice pale gold to a dark, crunchy brown. And when you're all done the griddles can be removed and tossed in the dishwasher. The unit also locks shut for easy vertical storage that saves precious cabinet space.

Our biggest complaint about the KRUPS GQ502D is that it takes longer to heat up and cook than other, smaller machines. We generally found ourselves leaving the waffles on the griddle for another minute or 2 past when the beeps indicated the waffles were done. We also found that the edges of the waffles cook much more than the centers. If you have a large family and need to churn out lots of waffles very quickly, these are small sacrifices to make, but in any other instance we'd suggest a smaller, round machine instead.

Read review: KRUPS GQ502D

8

Great for Whimsical Mornings


ThinkGeek Death Star


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$40
List Price
See It

Size: 7 inch diameter | Style: Classic
Indicator light lets you know when it's up to temperature
It's a Death star…for breakfast!
Easy to overfill
Takes a long time to cook

If you wake up every morning hoping to see the twin rising suns of Tatooine, the ThinkGeek Death Star can go a long way towards quelling your disappointment. After destroying a few Death Stars with a well timed syrup and cutlery ambush you're sure to have a good day, even if your dreams of being a real Jedi knight don't come to fruition. Plus it has an indicator light that knows when the irons are up to temperature, so you don't need an astromech droid to do the calculations for you.

As we all know, the Death Star had some fatal flaws, and its waffle maker brethren is no different. We found that you have to be very careful about the amount of batter you put in or it will overflow like Finn's bacta suit. And just as the Death Star inexplicably had to wait 15 minutes to get in range of the rebel base on Yavin 4, this machine takes much longer to cook a waffle than other models that we've tested. Those waffles are also quite thin. Still fluffier than the average frozen fare, but much thinner than a true Belgian waffle.

Read review: ThinkGeek Death Star


Why You Should Trust Us


Authors Steven Tata and Max Mutter have been leading TechGearLab's breakfast brigade since 2016, and in that time have personally tested over 80 breakfast-related kitchen appliances. In that time the duo have become experts in bringing restaurant quality breakfast prep into home kitchens.

We researched over 70 models for this review before buying the best of the best in every price range. We then spent more than 80 hours using those devices, one right after the other, and taste-tested all of the resulting waffles. This allowed us to thoroughly examines each model's user-friendliness, construction quality, and of course, waffle making ability.

How to Find the Right Waffle Maker


Theses are fairly simple devices, but don't let dreams of syrup drenched deliciousness cause you to snag just any one off the shelf. If you pay attention to a few minor details you can end up with a maker that is great rather than one that is just ok.

Testing the waffle makers  side by side.
Testing the waffle makers, side by side.

Waffle Type: Belgian vs. Traditional


The most important thing to consider in a waffle maker is what type of waffles it actually makes. Belgian waffles are the super thick and fluffy style that you likely associate with restaurants. Most people that want one of these devices are probably looking for these fluffy cakes with deep pockets for syrup and fruit.

On the other end of the spectrum is the traditional or classic waffle. These pastries are much thinner and more crispy. They are still much fluffier and more luxurious than frozen waffles made in a toaster, but also much thinner than true Belgian style fare.

The Death Star makes good waffles  but they are a little on the thin side.
Above you can see the thick Belgian waffles of the Presto FlipSide (left) and the thinner, classic waffles of the ThinkGeek Death Star (right).

To Flip or Not to Flip


Possibly the most significant feature of a home waffle maker is whether or not it has the ability to flip. Being able to flip the iron 180 degrees not only allows for more even batter distribution (and thus more consistent cooking), it can also make getting the waffle off the iron without tearing it to shreds infinitely easier. The downside is that models that flip tend to be more expensive, larger, and can only make a single waffle at a time. The Presto Flipside solves most of these problems thanks to its hinged design that keeps it both on the smaller and the less expensive side of things while still offering a flipping function.

Models that can flip  like the Presto FlipSide  make for more even cooking.
Models that can flip, like the Presto FlipSide, make for more even cooking.

User Friendliness


The last thing you want to deal with when making breakfast is guesswork, so you'll want a waffle maker that has at least a few indicators. At the very least you want something that alerts you when the iron is up to temperature. Many makers also have a built-in timer that lets you know when the waffles should be done. These timers are not always accurate, cooking time can vary based on the specific batter you use, but they at least give you a consistent reference point without having to remember to set a timer yourself. It can also be nice to have a shade knob that adjusts the temperature, so you dial in your preferred crispiness.

Shade knobs and ready lights  like those on the Oster CKSTWF2000  can make breakfast prep a little easier.
Shade knobs and ready lights, like those on the Oster CKSTWF2000, can make breakfast prep a little easier.

Ease of Cleaning


Luckily most waffle makers have dependable non-stick coatings, so you can generally get away with just wiping the griddle itself with a damp cloth once it's cooled down, and you should be good to go. The non-stickiness does perform better on some models than others, but even the bad ones can generally be remedied with some cooking spray. Some models even have removable griddles that can be placed in a dishwasher.

Some of the waffle makers we tested for this review.
Some of the waffle makers we tested for this review.

Overflowing batter and dripping condensation are the two most common sources of a messy kitchen when using a waffle maker. You can generally solve the former problem through some trial and error in finding the exact right amount of batter to put into your machine, but even so some models just tend to spill more batter than others. Similarly, some models tend to drip more condensation than others. Neither of these messes are very hard to clean, but if you want to streamline cleanup the removable drip tray of the Oster Flip makes things easier.

It can be easy to get a little overzealous with the batter.
It can be easy to get a little overzealous with the batter.

Capacity: Round vs. Square


Most one-at-a-time waffle makers opt for a round shape, while those make make multiple waffles generally default to a square shape (the Cuisinart Double Belgian being a notable exception). Overall, round waffles tend to cook better. Batter and heat are able to disperse more evenly in a circular environment, resulting in a more evenly cooked waffle. However, having round waffles means you can only make one waffle at a time. This is probably not ideal for a hungry family of four. Square waffles tend to have corners that are a bit more done than the middles, but the shape lets you make four square waffles at once in some machines. So you'll have to decide whether you want more even cooking or a higher capacity.

Storage


As lofty and admirable of a goal as it is, you're probably not going to make waffles every morning. Thus you're likely going to ant a waffle maker that can easily be stored out of the way when not in use. Two models in particular, the Presto FlipSide and the KRUPS GQ502D, make storage quite efficient and easy and they can lock and stand up vertically. In many situations this can save a lot of precious cabinet space.

The FlipSide locks in an upright position for easy storage.
The FlipSide locks in an upright position for easy storage.

Conclusion


Having, fluffy, cafe style waffles at home is both easier and less expensive than you may think. For just a small investment and some elbow grease for mixing up the batter, you can have a delicious brunch right in your own dining room. We hope our research has led you to the perfect breakfast companion.


Max Mutter and Steven Tata