The Best Coffee Grinders of 2017
Stale beans got you down? We researched over 60 of the top coffee grinders, then bought the best 13 and put them through 120 hours of testing, all so you can have the freshest coffee grounds possible. No matter what model you choose, switching from pre-ground to fresh, whole beans is going to improve the contents of your coffee cup. However, choosing the right grinder can mean the difference between a good cup, and a spectacular cup. We tested all of our grinders in a wide range of scenarios, so our testing results can lead you to the perfect grinder no matter your budget or brewing style.
Read the full review below >
Test Results and Ratings
|Displaying 6 - 10 of 13||<< Previous | View All | Next >>|
Analysis and Award Winners
Updated August 2017
After spending some more time using and testing the KitchenAid Blade we've decided to promote it to our Best Buy on a Budget Award winner. It Performs very similarly to our old budget pick, the Epica Electric, but is noticeably quieter. Both models are great shoestring budget options, but we think the KitchenAid Blade has a slight edge.
We've also continued to use the OXO On Barista Brain in the office and have been consistently impressed with the quality of coffee that it produces. In fact, many of our office mates have purchased the Barista Brain for their homes because their morning coffee was starting to feel quite mediocre in comparison.
Best Overall Coffee Grinder
OXO On Barista Brain Conical Burr Grinder
Considering how groggy our pre-caffeinated selves can be in the morning, we could all use a little more brain in our wake-up routine. The OXO Barista Brain delivers exactly that, with a sleek interface and built-in scale that makes sure you get the perfect amount of grounds. Not to mention it made the richest and most wonderfully nuanced cup of coffee of all our grinders. If you're the type of person who sips their coffee looking for the subtle nuances of your chosen beans, this is the grinder for you. The only drawback is that the noise it makes can be a bit grating, so you might wake some people up if you're in a house full of light sleepers. In that case you might want to check out the Cuisinart Deluxe, or you could just ditch the light sleepers, some things just aren't as important as coffee.
Makes an excellent cup
Very simple and intuitive controls
Precise dose-by-weight feature
Read full review: OXO On Barista Brain
Best Bang for the Buck
If you want a great cup of coffee but don't want to break the bank, the Capresso Infinity is for you. With a list price of $100 it certainly isn't a budget option, but it has the best taste quality to dollar ratio of any of the models we tested. In our testing it made a strong, intricate cup that was only a bit less refined than the cups from models that cost twice as much. To boot it has a nice, simple interface and relatively mess free operation that will keep your morning routine streamlined and frustration free (and the last thing you need before you've had your coffee is frustration). Overall the **Infinity represents only relatively minor sacrifices when compared to the top models, but costs significantly less, making it a shoe-in for out Best Bang for the Buck Award.
Makes a good cup
Simple and intuitive controls
Taste slightly inferior to top models
Read full review: Capresso Infinity
Best on a Budget
You don't have to break the bank to upgrade to fresh ground beans, and the KitchenAid Blade proves that point with aplomb. Listing for $50 (But often available for less than $30), this little grinder features simple, clean, and relatively quiet operation. We particularly like the removable grinding bowl, which allows for easy transfer from the grinder to your coffee making apparatus of choice. Sure, it doesn't make quite as good a cup as the more expensive burr grinders we tested. but it is still a step up from store bought pre-ground beans. If you want to class up your coffee without breaking the bank take a shot on the KitchenAid Blade, you won't be disappointed.
Easy to use
Inconsistent grind size
Read full review: KitchenAid Blade
Top Pick for Quietest Grinder
Cuisinart Deluxe Grind
Ninjas and lionesses silently stalking their prey are just a couple of things that come to mind when using the Cuisinart Deluxe Grind. This powerful yet quiet machine is able to create a very consistent grind size and a correspondingly great cup of coffee while avoiding that nails on a chalkboard feeling that some other grinders produce. Yes, it's still pulverizing coffee beans so it's not silent, but it is likely quiet enough that you won't wake the late sleepers in the next room. Plus it's easy to use and mess free, so much so that it almost won our Editors' Choice Award. Its price has also been slowly falling at many online retailers, so it is becoming a better value by the day.
Makes a great cup
Simple and intuitive controls
Read full review: Cuisinart Deluxe Grind
Analysis and Test Results
With coffee being one of the most highly consumed beverages in the world, choosing a coffee grinder is perhaps a more frequently required decision than buying a car. However there's one big difference: you can't test drive a coffee grinder. You can read about what kind of features and buttons and LED display it might have, which is helpful, but you can't quite take it for a spin until you've already made your buying decision and taken it home. And this might not be a big deal if all grinders were roughly the same, but there are different styles of grinders and prices that range from $20 to $200. Of course, they all grind coffee, but so many options and prices can leave you wondering if the more expensive models will really feel like a better investment for your morning cup or if you're better off with an option that just matches the colors in your kitchen.
So we selected 13 of the most popular and reputable grinders on the market, paid retail price, and test drove them for you. The nature of our tests revolved around the simple question, "Which grinder is going to help me make better coffee?" So we actually made coffee, lots and lots of coffee, trying to discover which grinder is going to make the best coffee and do so most effectively.
We dialed in each grinder to find its "sweet spot," brewing over 200 cups of coffee until we felt we had achieved the best possible brew with each machine. We did this making drip style as well as French press coffee to get a bigger picture of how each grinder performed. We tasted each sample in a giant all-at-once lineup and taste tested further in extensive side-by-side grinder face-offs. Each coffee was sampled hot as well as cool and darn good notes were taken all throughout the process.
Were we wired? You have no idea! I didn't know there was such thing as a coffee hangover until we started this review. But it was worth all the hard work as now we are confident that we can provide you with the best information around to select the coffee grinder that's right for you.
While taste is the highlight of the coffee experience, there are other things that a coffee maker (that's you) thinks about as they're using a grinder. Which button to press, which setting to use, how much to grind, how to get the coffee into the brewer without making a fat mess, and "Is this grinder going to wake up my roommate?" Well we thought about these things too and so we also rated each grinder for intuitive use, mess-free operation, and noise levels.
Upping Your Coffee Game
There are plenty of things you can do to make your morning cup more delicious, more adventurous, or more exciting. But if you ask around, just about every coffee professional is going to tell you that the first step to greater coffee glory is all in "the grind." Not only that, but having your own coffee grinder can be a handy convenience. Sometimes the coffee you crave isn't available pre-ground and you have to resort to a less exciting alternative or find a good friend who has the means to grind it for you. And although you can buy most coffee pre-ground, one benefit of using your own grinder is that it gives you the ability to find the perfect grind for your brewer. In our quest to produce the best possible cup of coffee from each grinder we sometimes achieved significantly better results by adjusting the grind by only 2 increments out of 40 (a small adjustment). Having your own coffee grinder not only allows you to grind coffee for brewing, but it allows you to grind it fresh and at just the right size for your brewing style. Dialing in the grind is uber important for getting the most out of your grinder. Don't miss out! Read more about it in our Buying Advice article.
And hey, maybe you're thinking, "Guys, it's just a cup of coffee." Maybe you don't care how good it tastes as long as it's super easy to make. Maybe you're on the hunt for a coffee grinder for occasional "emergency" use. Maybe someone gifted you two pounds of whole bean coffee and you just need something more efficient than your peppermill to turn it into the stuff of life before work each morning. Maybe you're looking for something that's super compact or for something that's super quiet. These are definitely things you'll want to consider when looking for a coffee grinder. Everyone has different needs and preferences. So what kind of grinder does it really take to get the flavor and convenience that's right for you? Read on. Let's start by taking a quick look at the types of grinders out there to help you find what you're looking for.
Types of Coffee Grinders
Blade grinders are both more affordable and compact than burr style grinders. This is great for the buyer who is trying to preserve their remaining kitchen counter space like a national park, wants to take their grinder along when they travel, or doesn't want to spend very much on a grinder. These grinders operate by spinning a blade which whacks the coffee beans apart. When using a blade style grinder you would continue shattering the coffee in the chamber until you think you've accomplished the right grind size for your brew. However, during this process some coffee bean particles are obliterated a bit more than others and the consistency of the grind becomes a mix of larger and smaller particles.
The majority of products we tested were burr style grinders because there were a larger number of top rated and reputable grinders in this category. Burr grinders have hoppers to store coffee in, a bin to grind into, and often have some sort of timer or dosing feature to select how much coffee to grind. These operate by crushing coffee between a pair of rotating burrs (pictured above). The coffee, fed from the hopper, continues to grind until it falls through an adjustable gap between the burrs and into a bin. These types of grinders are often thought to be superior to blade grinders in taste because of their ability to produce a more consistent grind size. However, in our testing we found that this is not always true.
Criteria for Evaluation
We've defined a good grinder as one that "helps you make better coffee with minimal inconvenience." But what does that look like in real world application? Well we pulled together a few criteria to define exactly that and used them to guide our testing and evaluation of each product.
In the following section we'll tell you what criteria we used, what tests we performed, and which items scored the highest. If you really want to nerd out with us and read about the details of our testing, pull up a chair and go to our How We Test article.
Quality of Taste
In a perfect world, a coffee grinder would give you the ability to brew what I like to call the "full flavored cup" of coffee. This means that you can experience the full potential of the coffee's flavor, that it tastes as good as it smells. In a full flavored cup there are layers of delicious flavor, some deep, some lively, sweet, juicy, chocolaty or whatever—all these layers are maximized and combined together in a beautiful balance to create a chorus of flavor that saturates your whole palate. The full flavored cup is full, rich, exciting, and void of any undesirable taste.
We wanted to evaluate each grinder's ability to produce this full flavored quintessence. We did this through an exhaustive trial and error process where we adjusted each grinder near its ideal setting, brewed a sample, tasted the results, and then adjusted the grind setting for better results. If the resulting brew lacked depth we would tighten the grind; if it were a bit bitter or dirty we would grind coarser. We repeated this process with each grinder until we felt that each grinder had produced the best possible cup that it was capable of for both drip style and French press style coffee.
I admit, we set the bar pretty high with our definition of the full flavored cup. But we had a few grinders prove that it is indeed possible to attain. The OXO On Barista Brain really stole the show here, landing a solid 9 for quality of taste. The bodied and full flavored cup that this grinder produced was unmatched by any of its competitors. The OXO gave us a very nuanced, sweet, full, well-balanced and rounded cup. Gosh! It was everything we could ask for! I mean, you could almost chew on the flavors they were just bursting from the cup. And while we noticed a trend of grinders producing a French press that was one point lower than their drip score, the OXO made an excellent cup of coffee for both brew methods. (Round of applause for the OXO.)
The Cuisinart Deluxe Grind, Baratza Virtuoso, and Breville Smart Grinder Pro followed behind, each scoring an 8. The Cuisinart Deluxe (NOT to be confused with the Cuisinart Supreme) stood out among these three in that it also brewed up a French press that matched the quality of its drip coffee. We found it interesting that each grinder highlighted different aspects of the coffee we brewed, even those that had similar or tied scores for quality of taste. The Cuisinart Deluxe made a great cup of coffee that was super smooth, sweet, and straightforward. It had a good balance of flavors that was "complete" but not explosive like its competitor the OXO. Check out our Buying Advice article to read more about flavor differences between grinders.
Three of the blade grinders we tested both scored a 5 although the Krups Fast Touch made a better drip style coffee than the Epica. The KitchenAid Blade also made a decently but not overly flavorful cup, no matte the brewing style we used. And although burr grinders are commonly thought to produce better taste than blade models, the Krups GX5000 earned only a 4, the Cuisinart Supreme Grind tested out to a 3, and the KitchenAid Burr scored a 2. We were unable to produce a cup of coffee with either of these grinders that could outmatch a blade grinder.
As you can see below, the Epica blade grinder (left) has noticeable inconsistencies in the grind, however the Cuisinart Supreme burr grinder (right) produced clumps of powder that resulted in an inferior brew.
Ease of Use
Ease of use is all about the question, "How helpful is this machine in getting me caffeinated (or decaffeinated if you're into that kind of thing)?" Wouldn't you love it if you pulled your brand new grinder out of the box and there was just one button on it that did exactly what you needed? Or let's say you give this thing as a gift to a friend or family member who doesn't want to read a manual, take lessons, or feel like they're operating a spaceship just to make a good coffee. A good grinder should help you make good coffee by being simple and intuitive to use.
Amidst all the pressing of buttons and reading of manuals, the OXO On Barista Brain enamored us with its simple and intuitive design, scoring a well-deserved 10 for ease of use. The unit has just one central control button with a surrounding dial and an easy-to-read LED display. The user turns the dial to select the number of cups to make then pushes the button to grind their desired amount of coffee. The grinder then has a built-in scale that stops the grinding process once the selected amount of coffee has been ground into the chamber—incredibly simple, and very accurate.
The Cuisinart Deluxe Grind was a very close second to the OXO. In comparison, the Deluxe Grind scored a 9, only lacking the precision of the OXO's built-in scale. Other models followed with 7 or 8 points, usually having some kind of dial that operated a timer to dose out coffee grounds. A few exceptions were the KitchenAid Burr and the Breville Smart Grinder Pro. The KitchenAid scored a 4 because the grind settings were difficult to operate; after adjusting from one grind setting to another (e.g.: from very coarse to very fine) the machine would dispense a mixture of both grind settings. The machine would either have to grind through a LOT of coffee to fully adjust to the next grind setting or be cleaned out after any adjustment. It's not uncommon for some previously ground coffee to remain among a coffee grinder's burrs, but for this machine, adjusting the grind size was problematic.
The Breville Smart Grinder Pro had us scratching our heads a bit. It has incredible precision and it has many features, but at the end of the day we scored it as a 6 for ease of use. This unit features a programmable memory, the ability to adjust grind time to the tenth of a second, and has almost half of its available grind settings designated for espresso making, but we often felt smothered by all the features in our field of vision. "Ah! What is all this? I just want to grind some coffee!" It's like all those apps on a new smart phone that you don't have any use for and your phone won't allow you to delete. The machine offers incredible precision that could be useful, but the cluttered design was a significant drawback to simply making a good cup of coffee. The Krups GX5000 also earned a 6. It was generally easy to use but has limited grind size settings. Fine coffee particles also tend to gather on the wall of the grinder, which requires some extra cleaning. The *KitchenAid Blade** also scored a 6. Its grinding bowl can be removed, which makes tranfersing grounds eays, but it also has a clumping problem that can be a bit frusterating.
Blade grinders were evaluated a little bit differently. Since their design does not allow them to perform some of the tasks that burr grinders handle, like measuring out the amount of coffee for the user, they require more work to operate. And while their "press 'n' guess" operation is incredibly simple, the blade grinders we tested do not allow the user to select their preferred grind size. However, the Epica Electric Coffee and Spice Grinder scored a 6, stacking up decently given its disadvantages as a blade. Features like the Epica's long cord with cord storage and its easy-to-view and easy-to-clean grind chamber left us feeling happy rather than frustrated after using it.
The Cuisinart Deluxe (below), OXO, and Breville all include a locking hopper which can be removed while full without spilling coffee beans. This is a handy feature which allows you to clean the machine or fill the hopper with another coffee without turning the entire unit upside down.
Coffee preparation is a pretty messy task if you think about it. You grind this stuff up into a bunch of tiny pieces so that it basically looks like dirt (yes, very very delicious and wonderful dirt). Then once you add water to it, you create this dark liquid that will stain whatever fabric it touches. So when selecting a grinder, or any coffee equipment for that matter, it's best to opt in for whatever damage control you can get.
While we were grinding away and brewing up our 200-plus coffees, we noticed certain grinders that stood out. We noticed the ones that we had to clean up after the most, that we avoided using because they made the biggest mess while we were trying to operate them or make what seemed like a simple transfer of ground coffee from the grind chamber to our brewer of choice. By far the most difficult to work with was the Cuisinart Supreme Grind (NOT to be confused with the Cuisinart Deluxe Grind). The Supreme spits coffee into the chamber from the side instead of from the top and because the grinder creates a substantial amount of dust the chamber gets caked and coated with coffee powder. When the chamber is opened, powder on the lid creates mess on the counter and static build-up in the chamber causes coffee to escape and magnetize to your hands and surrounding items. Once the coffee is removed the chamber remains dirty and should be rinsed. The Supreme Grind landed the lowest possible score of 1 for mess-free operation because we found ourselves painfully avoiding the hassle that this machine required. We got better at using it over time by inventing tricks to control its chaotic nature, but even then, the inconvenience of managing this machine's mess still clearly fell into the deal-breaker category.
Over the course of time we noticed that different grinders, not unlike roommates, each make their own special kinds of messes. While the Supreme Grind made the most mess during transfer to the brewer, the KitchenAid Burr (with a score of 4) would spill some coffee from the burrs if it was moved or the table was bumped; the Baratza grinders (each scoring a 6) would begin to expel a puff of coffee chaff onto the counter when the grinder was repeatedly used and the chamber was returned to its station; the Capresso Infinity made a little mess after a long time (we scored it as a 7) but was a bit difficult to wipe up after. The Krups GX5000 (with a score of 5) creates clumps of fine particles that stick to the wall of the grinder and need to be scraped off.
On the other hand, the Cuisinart Deluxe scored a 9 in the mess-free category, going virtually unnoticed while we were wiping up the little spills of the majority of grinders. The Breville and OXO tied with the Deluxe because they not only created very little mess but they also have a feature that allows you to remove a plate under the grind chamber to easily transfer any mess to the trash without having to move the machine or wipe up.
But the mess-free winner of the blade style grinders we tested is definitely the Epica Electric Coffee and Spice Grinder. We awarded this grinder a 9. The grind chamber twists off and the coffee easily transfers into your brewer with minimal mess. Afterwards the grind chamber can be quickly hand-washed under running water to remove residual coffee dust. The Krups, however, scored a 2 for mess-free because it was both inconvenient and time consuming to manage the ground coffee from this unit. The Krups requires that the whole unit is turned upside down, knocked and brushed to remove ground coffee, and cannot be submerged for further cleaning.
In the big scheme of things, a coffee grinder's job is to grind coffee, not necessarily to be quiet. But a noisy appliance can be a real pain, especially an appliance that you're likely to use first thing in the morning. You may have a sleeping baby or spouse, a house guest, an exhausted roommate, or maybe you're really just not in the mood for the sound of a loud motor crushing coffee beans when the sun's barely up.
To find the quietest grinder we started by busting out the decibel meter. While the decibel meter gave us quantifiable readings of volume levels, we only used this as a guide to our final scoring in this category. The decibel readings we took had some close calls and ties, yet it was obvious that some machines had a more agreeable frequency that was more like white noise, whereas others had high pitch whizzing motor noise that was much less appealing. Ultimately we asked ourselves the question, "If someone was sleeping in the next room and you had to press one of these buttons for 10 seconds, which one would it be?"
Honestly, choosing the quietest grinder was a piece of cake. The Cuisinart Deluxe Grind scored a solid 9 for quietness. Its sound quality had everyone saying, "Woah!" every time we used it. The Breville Smart Grinder Pro took a 9 as well, tying for highest score. Even though the motor noise had a less pleasant frequency, the Breville was still impressively quiet and even had a slightly lower decibel reading than the Deluxe Grind.
The blade grinders we tested (the Krups Fast Touch and Epica Electric Coffee and Spice Grinder) were both moderately loud, scoring a 4, but the loudest models were really the Cuisinart Supreme Grind and the KitchenAid Burr. We were almost afraid to turn these on. The Cuisinart Supreme came in with a 2 on quietness. It not only had the highest decibel reading but it also created the most noise—the rattling and crushing of beans along with a whirring motor that finished with a record-scratching sound. The KitchenAid Burr scored a 3 on quietness, having a slightly lower decibel reading but a screaming high pitch motor.
— Jared Marquez
Table of Contents
You Might Also Like