The Best Card Games of 2020
Monopoly Deal is an excellent card game, starting with the fact that it is not the same as its parent board game. It maintains the competitiveness of Monopoly, but with none of the boredom or forever-long duration. We love that this game doesn't rely on inappropriateness or shock value; instead, it's family-friendly. Deal is fun even if you only have two players (although 4-5 player games are even more entertaining), so it's good for cozy nights with your partner. Some of our testers have played this game for years and plan to continue, unlike several other one-and-done games. This game fits easily in a jacket pocket for transport to your local watering hole. Best of all, this is the least expensive game among all we tested, and it offers the greatest appeal.
Monopoly Deal usually takes new players a few games to really grasp, but then, it's off to the races. Some of the rules are unclear (intentionally?) about what is allowed or not, leaving room for interpretation that not everyone will appreciate. If you're looking for a deeply strategic game, this one might not be enough for you because it incorporates some luck of the draw aspects. This is also what keeps it fun for younger and older audiences playing together. Our team of testers has played many card games, and this one continues to rise to the top of the heap. It combines entertainment, replayability, and clever design for many ages and maturity levels to enjoy.
Scrawl receives unanimous praise among our testers for its hilarity. The overwhelming laughter comes not from the game itself, but the creativity of the players. It doesn't rely on cards with crude or gasp-worthy phrases. Instead, Scrawl gives a prompt and allows the imagination of the players to fill in the rest in the form of phrases and illustrations. This freedom makes it more replayable. Due to the speed of play, the cards are also not used up as quickly as in other prompt-and-response games, which helps preserve the game's freshness. A time limit for drawing and writing adds a fun amount of pressure. And because everyone "plays" simultaneously, there's no waiting around. At the end of a round, when the sequence of drawings and writings are revealed for all to see, we dare you to keep a straight face. Or, don't — let yourself laugh so hard it becomes a core workout.
There are a few small caveats worth mentioning. First, this game is pricey and comes with poor quality dry-erase markers. We recommend ordering an inexpensive pack of dry-erase markers separately. And while the prompt cards are PG (a few teeter on PG-13), we've seen a strong tendency for gameplay to get rather spicy. Maybe it's just us? However, with some self-censorship and removal of a few of the more suggestive card prompts from play, it could be appropriate for kids too. Note that while you do NOT need to be a good drawer to have fun in this game (poor drawings are often the winners, actually), convincing everyone to draw can be tricky. Scrawl might feel out-there but trust us — no game has ever made us laugh so hard.
Our Editors' Choice winner is an incredible value, but for folks seeking a game with more edge and complexity, Unstable Unicorns combines several compelling game aspects in a high-value product. The illustrations by creator Ramy Badie are cute and clever, in a fantastic, anime kind of way. We like that tactics are required to succeed in this game, pushing it beyond its aesthetics to become a well-rounded game. The interplay between lightheartedness (you're playing with charming unicorns) and cut-throat competition creates a fun dichotomy, and the moderate levels of complexity and strategy will keep this game coming out of the closet for more than just one game night.
Although the gameplay isn't for children, some adults might be turned off by the visuals of the game. We recommend giving it more than face-value judgment, though. If you ever want to spice it up, there are expansion packs for purchase separately (including an NSFW version). The instructions are long and tedious, though, and it took most testers 2-3 games before they were understood enough to play with a cohesive strategy. Factoring in that one game can take up to 30 minutes, this is a long to be learning. All things considered, this is an entertaining, competitive, and creative spin on strategic card games that we think lots of people will enjoy without spending too much money.
For fans of Gin Rummy, Speed, Kings Corner, or similar card games, Dutch Blitz should make its way onto your shortlist. This game of simultaneous speed-play inspires vintage fun, and it's a great addition to any cabin getaway. The frenzied, chaotic nature of the game supplies an entertaining mix of panic and satisfaction. It's family-friendly, so as long as kids are able to keep up with the pace, they can play along. The game works head-to-head well, and it can accommodate up to four players in its original pack or up to 8 with an expansion. This game is fun to play over and over and truly fits the pastime vibe.
While this game isn't complex, the instructions are less than user-friendly, which can make the game seem (on paper) more complicated than it really is. And if you're looking for a game of strategy, look elsewhere. This game is about shedding cards faster than your opponents, with little time or opportunity to employ thoughtful tactics. Despite these few drawbacks, Dutch Blitz has held a place high in our card game rotation for years, and we continue to love its charm and fast-paced fun.
If you haven't heard of this game already, let us introduce you to one of the most popular adult card games, Cards Against Humanity. If irreverent humor fits your friend group, this game will be an instant hit. Setup and explaining the rules take only a couple minutes at most, and within a single round, players are fully locked in and "get it." Gameplay revolves around a prompt card, with each player supply their own anonymous response card, aiming to get the judge of the round to pick their card by using shocking hilarity, cleverness, or both. This game paved the way for the array of NSFW (Not Safe For Work) adult games on the market, like an inappropriate grandfather, cranked up to 11.
Cards Against Humanity is not for everyone. This game offers heaps of vulgarity and swear words, which can be unabashedly offensive to many who don't appreciate this style of humor. If shocking indecency doesn't make you laugh, steer clear of this game. Know your audience, as there's no way to filter this polarizing game. The other drawback is that once you've played through all the cards, the entertainment of the game drops off sharply. Luckily, CAH has 600 cards in the starter deck, and a whopping 28 expansion packs available. They aren't free, but they do extend the life of this game. Regardless, the first time you play is guaranteed to be memorable (for better or for worse).
If you grew up with a video game console in the 1990s, the chances are that Boss Monster will conjure nostalgic feelings. The gameplay imitates a scrolling 2-D video game while you build your dungeon as an end boss. We like the role reversal of playing the bad guy (cue Billie Eilish), building a lair of traps and monsters to ensure the demise of the "heroes." This game has just enough luck of the draw involved to keep gameplay strategies fresh without the game falling into pure chance, which is a great balance. We also appreciate that the game is complex enough to allow everyone's strategy to evolve as they play the game more.
We admit that not everyone will fall for the aesthetic of this game, and the steep learning curve and long setup time will likely be dissuading for some. The instruction booklet has 21 pages (granted, the pages are small, but still). These directions are thorough and a helpful resource, but take time to read through and comprehend. The instructions also provide a link to an online how-to video, but we didn't find it very useful. Lastly, not everyone is looking for complexity, and Boss Monster feels more like a board (or video) game than most card games. If the look and description of this game are enough to draw you in, though, we think you'll be thoroughly entertained with this unique game.
Do you enjoy murder mystery parties? Love a game of deceit? Are you interested in theater? If you answered yes, you're going to love playing Werewolf. This game pulls each player's persuasive skills to the forefront. Player creativity is at an all-time high here. The game gives you your role, provides a basic framework, and the rest is up to the players. Werewolf accommodates large groups of players, and can easily be a party game for the right group of players. It's repeatable, and the illustrations create a clean aesthetic. If this style of game fits your friend group or large family, it can make you how with fun.
This game can be an absolute hit, but it can also flop. This depends heavily on all players being willing to get into character and act out their roles. Also, the instructions in the deck of cards and online aren't very helpful. If you've never played before, the first round is going to feel very confusing. It's very helpful to have someone playing who already knows how the game works. This game also requires a large number of players. These limitations prevent the game from winning an award, but for the right group that's willing to weave a story of deceit, Werewolf is an incredible game.
You are looking for a deck of cards that can bring the suspense? Exploding Kittens fits the bill. Knowing that any card you draw could be your last creates a healthy dose of anxiety to fuel this game's fun factor. It's super easy to set up and learn to play with really clear instructions and straightforward gameplay. Kids can also play along, and rounds are short enough that minimal commitment is required for this game. The cards themselves add some humor to the game, too.
As for drawbacks, strategy doesn't really factor into this game until the deck thins out. Although this builds suspense, it means that the first half of each hand is generally uneventful. This game can work with only two people, but we think it's much more fun with 4-5 people. And even with a well-played strategy, a lot of this game relies on luck. We also think this game is a little pricey for the entertainment it provides. Exploding Kittens is a novel game, though, and works great as a lighthearted filler between longer, more complex games.
What Do You Meme? adds a new twist to adult party games we've seen before. Instead of written prompts, this game has large picture cards of memes to which players submit their best response cards. Similar to Cards Against Humanity, the only strategy is to play to the humor or wit of each round's judge. Setup and leaning the rules is very quick. Winning and losing isn't really the focus, so you can quit once everyone has gotten their fill. This game really got us laughing several times, and it's at home at a house party.
The Achilles' heel here is replayability. We found that many parties lost interest in the game once the picture meme cards circled back for a second round (there are only 75 cards). Most of our test team enjoyed the game at first but then became bored. There are expansion packs for purchase, though, that would help extend the life of this game. We think Cards Against Humanity is the superior game in this genre because it comes with over 150 more cards and more provocative prompts and comments. If you love CAH but are looking for a new twist, What Do You Meme? satisfies that itch.
Why You Should Trust Us
Ross Robinson leads the testing team of competitive shufflers. Growing up with four siblings and a closet packed full of games gave him an early start at becoming a game night zealot. Still, when the Robinsons get together, someone is designated to bring a new game. Hosting game nights with friends on the reg, Ross brings plenty of experience and game knowledge to the card table. He has played many of the games tested with his nieces and nephews, and his past experience as an elementary teacher help him form an idea of what younger players want and need to hold their attention. Ross has played over 50 different card-style games as an adult and is constantly on the lookout for the next one to add to his collection.
We investigated stacks of games, read through hundreds of user reviews, and crunched the numbers before selecting the nine products reviewed here. We bought them and created a rubric to score each product. We read through instructions, counted cards, assessed the level of strategy and complexity, and to determine which games have longevity and which get played once and then sit on a shelf for years before ending up at Goodwill. We also asked friends and family to play these games and report back on their experiences, averaging their input to gain a broad consensus. We love card games and tried to do them justice by buying, opening, playing, fighting over, and assessing each model. Rest assured, there were many arguments regarding rules and interpretations along the way.
Analysis and Test Results
To resolve the fierce competition between these games, we cycled playing through them all back-to-back to rank and score each model's characteristics. Our testing rubric included five performance metrics; Replayability, Entertainment Factor, Strategy Factor, Design, and Ease of Setup. The products that rose to the top generally performed well in multiple, if not all, categories.
You shouldn't need to buy a new game every time you want to play. We've tested several games that are an absolute riot the first time we play them, then wonder where the fun went when we pull them out a second time. A game's replayability is essentially its ability to entertain over time, or to grow old and become no longer fun to play. We looked at how much fun each model is to play over and over in a single night, as well as how it ages over multiple game nights.
Monopoly Deal is one of the most replayable decks we've come across. Several testers pack these cards along on any camping trip or when heading to a favorite brewery, and it hasn't gotten old after years of play. Not only does it age well over time, but it's even fun enough to sustain an entire night of gaming. Dutch Blitz is another game that we've played for years without it losing its luster. We also expect Unstable Unicorns to remain on our shelf long-term. While the cards are entertaining themselves, the gameplay doesn't rely on their uniqueness. Instead, it's how you play the cards you receive, and there is a huge variety in the types of cards in this game to keep the game ever-fresh. Even still, should you ever want to spice things up further, there are four expansion packs available for this game.
Party games are notoriously poor at replayability. They often rely on shock value, which is more effective the first time you see it, not so much afterward. You can sustain the shock with expansion packs to continually inject new cards into the game, but this requires additional purchases by the consumer. Cards Against Humanity offers a whopping 28 expansion packs at the time of publishing, blowing the other games out of the water in this regard. What Do You Meme? impressed our testers least in this metric because it has fewer cards than CAH and fewer expansion packs available. It aged quickest for us. Scrawl is much more replayable than these games since the focus isn't on the cards as much as what the players create in response to the card. Also, the gameplay doesn't cycle through the cards nearly as fast as these other party games.
The most replayable deck of cards probably goes to Werewolf. Because the cards are essentially just character assignments, the game is unique each time you play it. Although it's certainly replayable on separate game nights, we don't think playing more than two or three rounds in a night is desirable — it can be exhausting to deceive so much.
What is the maximum amount of fun you have with a game? While this is admittedly subjective, we polled our friends and family to get their opinions on these games. We also play each multiple times and with varying numbers of players to get a feel for each product. Products that score well in this metric are engaging for a wide range of tastes. Age appropriateness and the number of players required for an entertaining game can also boost a product in this metric.
Monopoly Deal, Dutch Blitz, and Boss Monster are all fun with only two players, which isn't something we can say for the other games. We think this is a great asset for a game, allowing head-to-head fun. Sometimes, you just don't have the crowd to play larger games. All three games are still even more fun with more players, and they all generate their entertainment in varying ways. Deal is about cut-throat competition, Dutch Blitz generates fun from frenzied and fast gameplay, and Boss Monster gets a lot of its entertainment from its complexity and nostalgic video game vibe.
Scrawl came out as the most entertaining game among our testers, who are primarily adults. It's hard to overstate how much relentless laughter this game has given us. Although there's no profanity, there are some references that might not be welcome at every table, especially if younger players are present. It's possible to remove these cards from the deck and play with only the safer cards if you prefer. That said, a certain level of inappropriateness is also what makes this game laugh-out-loud hilarious. This game is best for 6 to 8 players, as the longer the chain of drawings and phrases generated by player input, the more it tends to diverge from the original prompt and become hysterical. Similarly, Cards Against Humanity and What Do You Meme? all require a larger number of players to be truly entertaining. Both games are much more profane than Scrawl — you've been warned.
Exploding Kittens is a pretty polarizing game for our testers. Some love the random, kooky, suspenseful nature of the game, while others were a bit bored with it. It certainly has its worth to many, but we found it to be hit-or-miss. Unstable Unicorns is able to conjure up some serious competition, so if you live to thwart your opponents, this is a great game for that. Werewolf, with the right size of group and willingness to get into character, can also be extremely entertaining. With the wrong people, though, it can be a dud.
If your ideal card game would have its strategic nature turned up to 11, pay attention here. While games of cards often employ less strategy than many board games, less does not mean none. We assessed the relative strategy level of each game by looking at how much skill influences outcomes. A game with a low skill ceiling generally relies on chance (the luck of the draw), while one with a high skill ceiling allows players to develop and carry out a plan, as well as leaving room to improve one's skill over time. Speed-based and the luck of the draw games have appeal, but not so much for those seeking strategy-based games.
The most strategic game for small groups is Boss Monster. In this game, you build a dungeon to lure in and destroy attacking heroes. The complexity of your dungeon is flexible and can change each turn however you like. Your choices also have actual consequences, too. Another layer of complexity is that you must not only defending your dungeon, but you can also sabotage the efforts of your opponents. Every time we play this game, our skill level increases and our tactics grow more elaborate. There is an element of responding to the cards you draw, but the emphasis is clearly on how you use these cards.
If you have a large, willing group, no game is more strategic than Werewolf. This game calls to action your skills of persuasion. The entire game consists of convincing everyone else that you are an innocent villager, not a werewolf invading and devouring another human each night. It doesn't get much more strategic than creating and acting out a character within a story based on deceit. It's brilliant. Monopoly Deal and Unstable Unicorns both offer a moderate amount of strategy. When played as two-player games, they rely more on the luck of the draw than anything else. However, with more players, the ability to strategize increases dramatically. For the party games, like What Do You Meme?, Scrawl, and Cards Against Humanity, the strategy factor is low, and none of them place much importance on winning or losing. Strategy is all but non-existent in Dutch Blitz, a game highly focused on speed.
The design and intent of a game influences user experience a great deal. Factors that we assess for this metric include the creativity and novelty each game provides. We also look for a balance of complexity and fluidity, while also realizing that simplicity can be a great design for a game. Lastly, as games have become more and more artistic, we judge aesthetics as well. We are generally pleased with the design of each game we tested.
Most of our testers voiced their appreciation for the design of Scrawl above all others. It's unique and inspires a lot of creativity. The rules are not complex, and the gameplay is simple. The game creates a portal into how individuals interpret images and phrases differently, and the results take hilarity to a whole new level. We like the design of Monopoly Deal for taking the best aspects of the board game while removing the worst and maxing out competitiveness. Boss Monster surprised us with unique gameplay that simulates a scrolling Nintendo or Sega game. We also like that Werewolf provides a completely different way to play with cards, engaging theatrical creativity and all-out deceitfulness from each player.
As far as aesthetics go, we like that art is increasingly becoming a selling point for card-based games. Werewolf stands out with clean aesthetics. The cards in Unstable Unicorns and Exploding Kittens are fresh, fun, and funny, adding another element to these games, and making the first time you play them all the more unique. Cards Against Humanity nails the simple and stark, black and white look. Boss Monster gets a nod here too. The cards are busy, but they are immediately identifiable as 90s video game illustrations.
Ease of Setup
Ease of setup includes the learning curve for first-timers and how long it takes to set up a round of play. We studied the included instructions and sought online resources provided by the manufacturers. For more complex games, we like to see handy cheat sheets included in the box. These are really helpful when you begin playing the game, as well as if you are a little rusty on the rules. We also considered how many patient rounds it took us before we were fully engaged and comprehending the rules and gameplay.
In general, party games are designed to be the easiest and quickest to set up and play. Cards Against Humanity and What Do You Meme? are the quickest games to explain to newcomers and to set up gameplay — just deal the cards. Exploding Kittens doesn't take too long to set up (shuffle, then deal) and while it requires some how-to explanations, the instructions are written out in a clear and even comical way. Scrawl is the most complex among the party-esque games we tested, with many pieces and less conventional gameplay. For all four of these games, a single round was all that was needed to understand the game and really get engaged for round two. Games such as Monopoly Deal and Dutch Blitz have a steeper learning curve, but only take a few rounds of play to get everyone on board.
Unstable Unicorns took us longer than we expected to figure out. We think the creators could develop a better presentation of how to play the game, as some testers zoned out during the long instructions. It took most testers a minimum of three full rounds before gameplay became fluid. The game goes come with eight cheat sheets to help if you haven't played the game in a while. Werewolf is woefully lacking in clear instructions. Had some of our testers never played this game before, we would have been left hanging and confused. There is a link to a video included in the deck, but that video doesn't give details on how to play; it's just an overview. Lastly, Boss Monster is the most complex game, requiring a whole booklet to explain the game. For all three of these games, we had to resort to using third-party how-to-play videos to gain a solid understanding.
Game nights are some of our favorite nights, and we hope our weeks of testing and assessing these products first-hand leads you to many evenings of competition, laughter, and good old' entertainment. Grab the game that calls to you, gather your friends, shuffle that deck, and play away. Game on!
— Ross Robinson