YI 1080p Home Review
Pros: Good video quality, relatively generous non-subscription services, inexpensive
Cons: Relatively narrow field of view, real time viewing sometimes choppy
Compare to Similar Products
YI 1080p Home
|Price||$60 List||$120 List|
Check Price at Amazon
|$40 List||$35 List|
$24.99 at Amazon
|Pros||Good video quality, relatively generous non-subscription services, inexpensive||Great Video quality, good real-time viewing, relatively inexpensive||Good video quality, inexpensive, user friendly, generous non-subscription services||Inexpensive, user friendly||Good video quality, very inexpensive, user friendly, generous non-subscription services|
|Cons||Relatively narrow field of view, real time viewing sometimes choppy||No scheduling||Real time viewing can be laggy, saves only 12-second video clips every 5 minutes, pan feature somewhat inefective||Real time viewing is sometimes laggy, limited cloud storage options||Real time viewing can be laggy, relatively narrow field of view, Saves 12-second clips only every 5 minutes|
|Bottom Line||A mix of good quality, decent non-subscription services, and low price that makes for a great value||A good all-around camera whose real strong point is its integration with the Amazon Key||A slightly upgraded version of the Wyze Cam v2 that likely is not worth the extra cost||A good and inexpensive model that offers basic functionality||The best budget option on the market, by a long shot|
|Rating Categories||YI 1080p Home||Amazon Cloud Cam||Wyze Cam Pan||Blink Mini||Wyze Cam v2|
|Monitoring Performance (30%)|
|Video Quality (30%)|
|App Ease Of Use (25%)|
|Real Time Viewing (15%)|
|Specs||YI 1080p Home||Amazon Cloud Cam||Wyze Cam Pan||Blink Mini||Wyze Cam v2|
|Power Source||Wall Outlet||Wall Outlet||Wall Outlet||Wall Outlet||Wall Outlet|
|Mounting||surface||surface, walls||surface||surface, walls||surface, walls|
|Static Field of View (degrees)||112||120||120||110||110|
|Free Features||Activity alerts, 6-second Activity Alert videos stored in YI Cloud for 7 days||Activity alerts, 24 hour history of activity clips||Activity Alerts, 14-day history of activity clips, motion detection zones||Free trial through 2020 (see paid features), activity zones, basic motion alerts||Activity Alerts, 14-day history of activity clips, motion detection zones|
|Paid Subscription Features||Standard- 15 days motion detected video for up to 5 cameras
Premium- 15 days CVR for 1 camera
|Basic- unlimited clip downloads, person alerts, motion zones, 7 day history, supports up to 3 cameras
Extended- basic plus 14 day history and supports up to 5 cameras
Pro- basic plus 30 days of history and supports up to 10 cameras
|n/a||Basic- 2 hours of motion activated clips saved on the cloud, old clips automatically delete to make room for new ones, support for 1 camera
Plus- same as basic, but support for an unlimited number of cameras
|Monthly Cost (one camera)||$10- Standard
$15- Standard for 30 days
$20- Premium for 30 days
Our Analysis and Test Results
The YI Home provides a lot of performance for quite a small price tag. However, for most people on a tight budget the slightly lesser but still good video quality of the Wyze Cam v2 may be a better value.
The YI Home was a fairly average performer in our testing (see table above), but its far below average price makes it a great value. In the following sections we discuss all the different tests we conducted to establish the YI Home's overall score.
The YI Home offers good non-subscription services and somewhat lackluster subscription services. Combined, this resulted in an average score of 6 out of 10 in this metric.
Monitoring Services With/Without a Subscription
The YI Home offers a much more generous non-subscription package than most cameras. For no additional cost the camera will save a 6-second clip every time it sees motion, and will save a 7-day history of those clips on the cloud for your viewing pleasure. In our testing it generally took the Yi Home about 30 seconds to reset before it would capture another 6-second clip. That means you can miss a lot of the action if there is constant movement in front of the camera, but you'll still get to see whatever triggered the camera. Notably, this is better than the other great budget option, the Wyze Cam v2, which only records 12 seconds once every 5 minutes. Still, these clips and the 7 day history means you can go on vacation and come back to a mostly complete video history of what transpired whilst you were gone. This is much more generous than most brands, as Canary offers only 24 hours of history without a subscription, Nest offers just 3 hours, and Samsung offers no history at all. NetGear is the only brand that really compares, as it offers a 7 day history of motion activated clips for free. Blink also lets you set a clip length for motion activated clips and will save 2 hours of them on the cloud, which is somewhat comparable. But, unlike other cameras, the YI Home lets you save as much video you want to a micro SD card. The only downside with saving to an SD card is that your footage will be gone if someone steals the camera. But you can always disguise your camera.
If you're willing to pay for a subscription, YI does offer more services, but not quite as much as the paid fare of other brands. For $10/month you can either get a 15-day history of all the motion that is seen by up to 5 cameras, or a 24/7 video history for one camera. Upping the price to $20/month extends that history to 30 days. By comparison, Nest offers 10 days of 24/7 history for multiple cameras for $10/month, or you can buy a whole year up front for $100. You also get advanced features like more descriptive activity alerts, the ability to tell the camera where not to look for motion (like outside the window), and facial recognition (for the IQ models), all advanced features not available on the YI Home
Bottom line, we think the YI Home's non-subscription services are generous enough that you can effectively get the peace of mind of having a security camera at a low price. However, if you're willing to invest in a long term subscription, we would suggest spending a bit more upfront as well with a Nest camera, as their subscription services and overall video quality are noticeably better.
This is another reason the YI Home lost a few points in our monitoring performance testing. The microphone often produced a garbled sound. To understand what somebody was saying they had to be right next to the camera. This likely won't feel like a huge loss for most users, but if you're really concerned about the audio quality of your security camera clips we found that Canary cameras have the best microphones. The Yi Home does offer 2-way audio, so you can talk to anyone who passes by the camera vis the YI app.
The YI Home found itself just earning a spot in the upper echelon with a score of 7 out of 10 in our video quality testing.
We were quite impressed with the full high definition sensor in the YI Home camera. In our testing it produced very clear, crisp footage that was nearly as good as the footage from the top scoring Nest Cam IQ, and noticeably better than the footage from the Blink XT. The video also had almost no distortion around the edges, something rare in a security camera. However, that lack of distortion comes at a bit of a price. The YI Home's field of view is just 112˚, which is noticeably smaller than the 130˚+ field of view you'll get with most higher end models. It is in line with other budget models, however, as the Blink XT offers a 110˚ field of view.
The YI Home's night vision mode is fairly clear, with faces looking a bit dark but recognizable. This performance was very similar to that of the Nest Cam, with only the new Nest Cam IQ offering noticeably better night vision.
App Ease of Use
While we didn't find any app particularly difficult to use, the YI app was towards the bottom of the scoreboard, earning a 6 out of 10.
The app was by no means frustrating to use, its interface just felt a bit less intuitive than other offerings. When compared to the super streamlined Nest app, the YI app felt a bit more arcane and required clicking around through more menu options before we found what we were looking for. After a very small learning curve we had no trouble navigating the app and certainly wouldn't consider this a dealbreaker, but other companies are a bit better at designing a digital user experience.
Real Time Viewing
The YI Dome offers fairly average real time viewing performance, earning a score of 6 out of 10 in our testing.
Generally the video that came through when we turned on live viewing with the Yi Home was fairly crisp. Not quite as crisp as the saved video clips it produces, but close. We measured the latency at just 2 seconds, which was the lowest latency of any of the cameras we tested. However, it lost some points because the live video feed could be quite choppy at times. Overall we felt the real time viewing experience was acceptable, if slightly frustrating when the choppiness got bad. If real time viewing is your main concern, you really can't beat a Nest Cam, but the YI would satisfy most users.
The Yi Home can stand on any horizontal surface and must be plugged into a standard outlet.
The YI Home represents a great value. With it you get about 70% of what you'd get from the top end models, at about 20-40% the price. Plus, most of those high end models require buying a subscription to be really useful, whereas the YI Home is an effective tool even without a subscription. Most of the same can also be said about the Wyze Cam v2, which may be a better value for those on a tight budget.
The YI 1080p Home is a capable little camera that offers much of the performance of high end models at a much lower price.
— Max Mutter and Steven Tata